Should I replace my Mercedes-Benz C220 with a Honda CR-V for better performance in snow?

I currently run a 2001 Mercedes-Benz C220 CDI Elegance saloon. The car has done just over 80,000 miles and is in excellent condition. During the past two winters, due to the snow, I have not been able to get out of my drive and when I eventually did, my road is ungritted and the Mercedes-Benz went nowhere. I am considering replacing the car with something newer with 4-wheel-drive capability and I would welcome your advice. A trade-in allowance of £3,000 has been mentioned by a local Honda garage for a CR-V although I would not buy new. I am not a petrol head so I don't really know what else is available to meet my requirements. I believe that a petrol driven engine would be more appropriate as I do not drive more than 8,000 miles a year. I have in mind to spend up to £20,000 overall and would grateful of any advice you can give me.

Asked on 4 June 2011 by RM, Chipstead, Surrey

Answered by Honest John

Yes, a current shape CR-V makes sense, preferably on 17-inch wheels, but 18-inch wheels are still okay. It will be even more capable in the snow on a set of winter tyres, and this time of year is the best time to buy them. I fit my Michelin Alpins to a separate set of rims and swap them over at the end of October.

Tags: suvs wheel sizes 4wd driving in snow winter

Similar questions

Can you recommend a car suitable for rural roads in ice and snow, perhaps with switchable 4wd/2wd?

I live in a hilly rural area with local access being a problem in icy/snow conditions. I also have to travel to rural schools as part of my job. I want to change my car but don't want a big fuel guzzling...

Please recommend a 4WD petrol vehicle for negotiating icy rural roads?

The heavy snow over last November and December left me marooned for days because our lane was never cleared. Although fond of my ageing Polo estate, I'd have felt more confident negotiating icy rural Somerset...

I recommend your correspondent EC considers an Audi A3 Sportback for use in wintry conditions.

Your correspondent EC, via email, appears to have identical needs to mine, except that our dog is a Springer Spaniel, not a Lab. I also drive 12,000 miles a year and make frequent trips to the Scottish...

Related models