Slugs an snails

I wrote to you several weeks ago regarding trading in my 5 year old X-Type Jaguar 2.0 diesel estate for a smaller car. You helpfully suggested a Mazda and I am currently looking at a Mazda 3. Doing a bit of research and it seems the 1.6 petrol isn't the best choice, described as “sluggish” in some reviews I have read. Because of the mileage and type of driving I am now likely to do this is the model I was looking at. Mileage anticipated around 10k per annum and mostly around town, with probably one trip per month of a 200-mile motorway trip, occasionally two trips. Main question therefore is if I go for a diesel, am I going to have problems with diesel particulate filters that we read so much about in your column? Also can you tell me what type of timing belt there is on the petrol and the diesel? I would like to go in to a dealer with as much technical knowledge as possible as I am a 59 year old widow and so now do not have the resource of my husband's technical knowledge.

Asked on 28 November 2011 by AR, Knowle

Answered by Honest John
I didn't find it sluggish. In fact I preferred it to the much more powerful 2.2 diesel. See test and video here: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/mazda/mazda-3-2009.../ "Out on the road, the base model 105PS petrol with 5-speed manual is a delight to drive. It’s comfortable, rides well, grips firmly, feeds back what’s going on to the driver and generally puts a smile on your face within the limitations of a 105PS petrol engine." Reviews depend on who has written them. If the reviewer is a Porsche fanatic then of course a Mazda 3 1.6 will feel sluggish. If he is open minded and judges as everyman it won't.
Similar questions
I am looking at buying a new car either the A3 or Mazda 3 which would you recommend overall has a package eg. reliability, Longevity , comfort, Appearance and resale value , running costs?
We have a 1999 Felicia 1.3, bought one year old in 2000. It has been superb - very cheap and very reliable - doesn't owe us a penny and I am now a Skoda fan. It will need replacing this year. It's on...
I'm looking for a second hand car - a smallish but stylish family hatchback - and am keen on diesel's mpg and torque but am mindful of the cautionary tales you tell of subjecting these to short runs -...
Related models
Stylish looks. Excellent steering and handling. Good quality interior. Impressive 2.2-litre chain cam diesel engine. Facelifted for 2012 and even better.