What 4x4 should we get to replace a Hilux?

Some advice on what to buy next please.

We have a Toyota Hilux and we need to swap it for something smaller and cheaper to run. We have 2 – 3 wet labradors so need dog space, 4 seats and proper 4x4 (gundogs so not just wet Tesco car parks) and ground clearance. A Suzuki Jimny would be perfect, but they are 2 seats only. We used to have a 54 plate X-Trail. Some SUVs look okay on paper, but I’m not convinced of their 4x4 capability and ground clearance.

Would appreciate a steer on what to look at.

Asked on 2 July 2025 by Boris Sussex

Answered by Craig Cheetham

Given the criteria that you mention, the model that really jumps out to us is the Subaru Forester. There's a reason why farmers like them so much. The Subaru Outback and Subaru Tribeca would also fit the bill. Also consider the Mitsubishi Outlander, which is respected for its off-road ability and the Land Rover Discovery Sport, which wouldn't be allowed the name if it was no good off-road.

Tags: 4x4s buying advice

Similar questions

Which cars have reasonable ground clearance?

What's the most economical, reliable and comfortable automatic SUV with 4x4 for around £20k?

We live up a steep hill on an unmade road. I do low mileage (6000 a year or so) but have been spoilt with my current electric car auto gear box which is obviously silky smooth perfection! The new house...

What car do you recommend for someone who suffers from arthritis in the hands?

I'm looking for a 4x4 car about 10 years old that is easy for someone who suffers from arthritis in the hands, an automatic with an easy to move gear stick. We currently have a Freelander which requires...

Related models