What engaging to drive car do you recommend?

I'm after a used car to replace my rapidly aging Peugeot 207. My criteria are a budget of £18k, 2017 or newer, 50k miles tops, manual petrol, sub 9-ish seconds to 60mph, saloon, hatchback, estate or decent size coupe (I'm too tall for an MX-5). Most importantly it must be engaging to drive, with excellent feel through the steering and gearbox and with decent handling


Every new-ish car I've driven recently has felt really numb to drive so I'm really hoping you can help.

Asked on 2 July 2025 by Toby Pratt

Answered by Matt Robinson
If you were to go for the coupe option, a BMW 2 Series could be worth a look. They're great fun to drive and even the base 218i will do 0-62mph in under 8.8 seconds. We'd go for the 220i at least, though, as the four-cylinder engine is smoother. Just be aware that manual-equipped cars are in the minority, particularly on the larger-engined versions - some patience might be required when hunting for your ideal example.
Similar questions
What in your opion is the most underrated SUV?
I'm looking to buy a BMW 3 Series convertible, looking from late 1990's to late 2000's, Looking to see what would be the best model, engine, (no diesels), and colour. Also what should I expect to pay for...
I am looking for a Rover 75 and can't seem to find out which were built by BMW and which engine is a BMW engine. There is a 1.8 petrol, 2.0lt diesel and a 2.5 V6 petrol, don't really want a diesel so it's...
Related models
Understated but handsome styling. engaging driving experience regardless of engine, M240i offers true sports car ability at a relatively affordable price.