What's the best premium estate car for £25,000?

I have around £25,000 to spend on a used estate car. I want to replace my old 2010 Volvo XC70 which is dependable but boring. I can't decide between the BMW 530 XDrive, Mercedes-Benz E350, and Audi A6. I do about 12,000 miles per year and would like better performance but need storage space for my fishing gear. What would you buy?

Asked on 18 January 2023 by David Kent

Answered by Andrew Brady
How about a Volkswagen Golf R Estate? It's a bit smaller than the cars you're looking at but very practical for its size and a lot of fun. You'll get a choice of tidy examples from around 2017 within budget. Alternatively, a Jaguar XF Sportbrake sounds like it could fit the bill. They're great to drive, feel pretty special and should have plenty of room for your fishing gear.
Similar questions
I am a 73 year old petrol head. I have a 2016 BMW 520 SE Touring and a 2011 Porsche Boxster 2.9. They are both great cars and fulfil all my needs. However, I am downsizing and really only need one car....
I currently own a Mercedes-Benz SLK 300. I love its acceleration, looks and quality. However, I feel I now need a larger car with more boot space and rear seats. I don't want a convertible anymore but...
I live in London and the impending ULEZ extension forces a reluctant sale of my much loved Euro5 BMW 640d. Everything about this car has been superb for the past five years but now is the time to move...
Related models
Attractive and comfortable family estate, thanks to standard fit self-levelling suspension. Available with all-wheel drive. Flat load floor with up to 1700 litres of boot space.
Immense cross-country pace. Comfortable and practical. Surprisingly economical at a cruise. Also available as an estate.