Which car do you recommend as a first car?

My daughter is 17 and learning to drive. Firstly, is it best to put her on our car insurance or buy her own car and start insurance by herself?

She is interested in low cc Corsa or would she be better off with a Citroen C1,Toyota Aygo or Peugeot 107? Or what would you recommend.

Is it a good idea have a black box fitted?

We are thinking of paying up to £4,000. She will be going to university in a year's time.

Asked on 8 February 2022 by Michael McCoy

Answered by Andrew Brady
Buying your daughter a car and starting her own insurance policy is probably a good thing as she can gain some independence and start building up her own no claims bonus. However, it might not make a lot of sense if she's going to university in a year and isn't planning on driving while she's there. Most students see a car as an unnecessary expense and she'll soon lose any NCB she's built up if she doesn't have a car insured in her name while she's away.

If you'd like to buy her a car anyway, an Aygo/C1/107 would be a good choice with low running costs. If she'd prefer something a little bigger, we'd rate a Ford Fiesta (with the reliable 1.25 petrol engine), Hyundai i20 or Toyota Yaris over a Corsa.

It's worth shopping around for insurance quotes on any car you're considering, and you might find that most insist on a black box.
Similar questions
I recently passed my driving test and am looking to buy my first car. Unlike most new drivers, I am in my 40s and the car I want is a family saloon. How do I find the best value insurance in my situation?...
What is black box insurance? Do I buy my own ‘black box’ or does the insurance company supply it?
My 17 year old son has had a telematics box fitted for the full duration of his two months of driving since he passed his test. His driving has been improving generally with a general reduction of 30-40%...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer