Black death

Just over a year ago I bought a new (pre-reg) FIAT 500 1.25 diesel (I mean the type of fuel, not the confusingly ‘Diesel’ branded car). I used it as a 'town car'. The reason we bought it was so as to stop tanking around town doing school runs in our big Volvo estate. Fuel efficient, low mileage, low carbon emissions etc., it seemed like the perfect car. Until, that is, it basically blew its own engine. My husband and children were driving just outside Edinburgh, where we live and suddenly there was a huge bang, smoke filled the car and quickly covered the whole of the A90. My family obviously had to screech to the side of the road and bail out. The engine wouldn't switch off and sounded, according to my husband, as though someone was driving it at high speed in first gear. Big drama, police, fire engine, etc. The FIAT dealer has had the car since that weekend and quickly ascertained that the engine had ''died'' and this was due to a fault in the car. FIAT paid a visit and decided that the warranty would provide me with a new engine and various other bits and pieces totalling just under £7,000. Keep in mind I bought the car for about £8,700. Now I’m nervous that once it's repaired the same thing will happen again. On your website I discovered “500 diesels no good for short runs from cold or town use. Leads to DPF failing to self-clean. What can happen is that excess diesel fuel that was supposed to burn hotter and regenerate the dpf does not and instead seeps into the sump, gradually raising the level of sump oil to the point that the engine starts to run on it, cannot be stopped and therefore self-destructs. Vital to check sump oil level regularly.” So, it all begins to make sense. But no one at the dealer told me any of this.

Asked on 19 December 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Pages 94 and 95 of the handbook tell you that the "oil exhausted" warning light lets you know if oil has degraded and needs to be changed. This should have happened long before the oil has been contaminated to the extent it has risen to a level that the engine could start running on it. FIAT was very concerned about what happened, initially denying that any 500s had been fitted with new engines for this reason, and got onto your case and that of another reader. Any reader experiencing this problem with a FIAT should e-mail lauren.bell@fiat.com I’d better add that, over 20 months, my own company FIAT 500 1.2 petrol model has been completely faultless.
Similar questions
I want to buy a Range Rover Sport 3.0 HSE, and I'm aiming to secure an 11 plate with 12 to 20K miles on the clock. However I have a dilemma and it’s all about the diesel engine - for years I have done...
I bought a Fabia vRS in February and it has the oil usage problem. The had the consumption test done and was informed that it was to have the breather modification done. Since then the car is still using...
I have read that adding two-stroke oil to diesel helps keep the pump and injectors lubricated. is this true and would you advocate this. My car is a Skoda Superb 1.9TDI PD130.
Related models
Stylish and full of character. Really affordable to buy. Low running costs.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer