My neighbour has reported a minor accident involving us both to her insurance company - how should I proceed?

About 1 month ago my neighbour, living opposite, reversed her car into mine as she negotiated joining the road from her drive. The damage appeared to be slight. We agreed that I would get a couple of estimates and she would settle without involving respective insurance companies. This I applauded given your rhetoric regarding greater costs in raised premiums, etc, should a claim be made not exceeding £500.

I duly obtained two estimates, one from my regular garage that quoted something in the region of £700 and the other, from an equally reliable source, for just under £400. In order to encourage settlement "privately" I said that I was prepared to waive the additional £100 demanded by the second outfit should I wish for a perfect paint colour match (my car is oldish and doubtless the finish has faded). Both estimates were identical in parts needed to rectify the damage - it seems that my own car-specific garage has greater labour charges and overheads. I was quite happy to go along with the provider of the lower figure.

Here is my dilemma: presumably acting on the advice of a "helpful" relative my neighbour has reneged on the arrangement and has now reported the matter to her insurance company, informing me that a Mr So-&-So will be getting in touch with me. He hasn't done so yet and I wonder how long it will be before he does. I have not told my insurance company about the situation. I was inspired by JA of Surrey who got the damage to his Bentley repaired and sent the bill to his council's waste contractors threatening court action if they did not pay up. I am in a different and rather awkward position as I do not wish to cause upset with my neighbour for obvious reasons. Also, insurance involvement is now a fait accompli. What do you suggest is my best move given these circumstances?

Asked on 4 July 2011 by PA, East Preston

Answered by Honest John
Now you have no choice. You have to report it to your insurer and you will be penalised for being involved in a claim by a hike in your insurance. You can sue her for that separately. Bit complicated to sue her for subsequent years, but you could get your broker to work out how much it will cost altogether. The Supreme Court needs to outlaw the unreasonable abuse of insurance law so that if two parties agree to settle over minor damage there should be no requirement to inform either insurer and claims hikes that far exceed the cost of the damage for years to come.
Similar questions
I was involved in a car accident last year and the other party admitted liability. His insurance company rang and confirmed liability both to me and my insurers. My insurance duly paid for all the repairs...
Please can you help me? At the end of last year I loaned my car to a Missionary friend who returned to this country for Christmas, who was aged 55 with a clean licence and full NCB when he owned a car...
I have been following your correspondence concerning "Claims Management" and whiplash scams. Can you give advice what to do at the time of an incident, please? Is it possible to deter the other party...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer