Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - Benet

My Panda has been fun and reasonably enjoyable but now the head gasket has gone. That will be £600. And then there are other nuisances like an airbag light warning light that won't go out, decomposing rear exhaust box, balding tyres... The next MOT/ service is not till March but then I anticipate shelling out another 4-500. So if I spend say £1k a year on keeping this car on the road, I am saving shelling out for something new. But I do worry it's not that safe anymore, for a daily 36 mile motorway commute. Any thoughts??

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - tyro

Depends.

In general, the cheapest course of action is to either

a) keep repairing the car you've got, (unless you are faced with a very, very large sum), or

b) replace it and buying something very, very cheap and running it until it needs some money spent on it.

Most of us avoid these cheap courses of action, and replace the car we have with something newer and more expensive and more desireable - and, hopefully, more reliable.

So the question really is "Do you fancy a change, or do you love your current car?"

I have no reason, based on what you've written, to assume that your car isn't safe. I can't know that it is, of course, but I don't see why it shouldn't be.

(Incidentally, I'm in a similar position - my 9 year old Ford Ka has serious rust problems, and I'm still trying decide when to replace it with something else. But I have do doubts that it is perfectly safe.)

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - Benet

Sensible advice and very well put. THanks!

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - SteveLee

Well it won't be worth much unrepaired and £1000 isn't a huge amount of money to keep it on the road, modern Pandas are pretty reliable. I'd keep it.

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - Collos25

Am reading correctly 600 for a head gasget are you haveing one manufactured from gold on this engine around 3 hours work max 250 would be on the top side.

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - Benet

I've been quoted a total price including labour, parts consumables and the often overlooked VAT, from my regular independent garage, whom I trust. However I do happen to live in a rather dear area.

Fiat Panda 1.1 (2004) - Repair or replace? - grimep

I think airbag warning light is on this year's list of new MOT fails, not sure if its part of the test yet or about to go-live... unfortunately it will probably mean a lot of otherwise OK cars will be heading for the scrapyard.