Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - dieseldogg

As above, I was in checking if my second hand rims were OK regarding offset, being 59mmagain 50mm.

Before I fitted all 4 winter tyres.

He says why do I not just put 2 tyres on the front as that is what most people are doing locally.

I near got lynched last year for wondering would this not be a better solution than no winters at all.

Cheers

M

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - nortones2

Does that include the BMW drivers?

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - dieseldogg

Hey, well spotted!, I ommitted the FWD, not many folks in my local community drive a big Merc Or a BMW, but if they do i would presume they fit them to the rear.

Sniff!

A sales was in am today in a sleek sexy SL Merc, ( & he expected me to purchase offen him?)

i said that must be fun in the Snow,

Yes he said that is why I have just fitted 4 brand new winter tyres.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - thunderbird

He says why do I not just put 2 tyres on the front as that is what most people are doing locally.

Not a good idea to fit Winter tyres in pairs regardless of the car being front or rear wheel drive, it unbalances the handling.Got ors from www.event-tyres.co.uk, great price and fitted within 2 days.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - madf

There is a video on U Tube showing what fitting winter tyres on the front does.. If you want a U turn at 30mph, go ahead and fit on the front only.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCyiBoTxCao&feature=related

Your fitter is a danger to others.

Edited by madf on 07/12/2011 at 15:21

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - SteveLee

That video test isn't rigged at all...

It doesn't take a genius to spot the all-season tyred car was, in both braking tests, on the icey side of the track, the winter tyre-shod car had nice (relatively grippy) snow to stop on.

It also doesn't take a genius to spot that the ABS has been defeated on both cars, a rotating set of rear wheels would, in most instances, prevent the car spinning under braking. The defeated ABS would also accentuate the winter tyre advantage.

I drove throughout the worst of last winter with just front all-seasons (Citroën C5 V6) - it was fine. I tried throwing it around in a snowy car park it handled perfectly safely and predictably.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - TeeCee

It's a very common strategy in the ex-Soviet Central European states, where you aren't going anywhere without snows and money's tight. In that part of the world they take for granted what we consider to be extreme weather, so they know what they're doing.

The secret is to drive like you have summers on and only rely on the snows to get up hills etc. Attempting to actually use the additional grip of the snows to corner faster will lose the back end sharpish. As most people have a tendancy to lift off when things come unstuck, this can get nasty as the sliding back overtakes the front instantly. In a FWD car with fronts only, a dab of additional throttle to pull the thing back into line is the correct (if counterintuitive) action to take.

It is a better solution than no winters at all, as long as you remain aware of the limitations and drive accordingly!

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - dieseldogg

That last line is exactly what my sensible tyre fitter mate said.

And imho & experience there is a slice of the rural community with more than a smidgen of motoring nous particulary in respect of driving in poor traction conditions.

Anyway would I be revealing my age if I mentioned a very popular FWD car that had a tendancy to somewhat dramatically lift off oversteer even when running on 4 good & matched tyres?

Only experienced as a passenger mind.

Edited by dieseldogg on 07/12/2011 at 16:07

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - madf

I grew up on Minis (pre 1970s) with lift off oversteer. Not fun when the car involved is spinning downhill towards you...Eeek!

Winter tyres on front only = recipe for spinning.

Since most of us don't live in the country - or just on the edge.. what rural people do in winter if of no use - (and they have tractors to pull them out of ditches)

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - thunderbird

In a FWD car with fronts only, a dab of additional throttle to pull the thing back into line is the correct (if counterintuitive) action to take.

It is a better solution than no winters at all, as long as you remain aware of the limitations and drive accordingly!

How can you drive accordingly, in bad weather you are more likely to be taken by surprise and when that happens with unmatched tyres front and rear tyres being aware of the limitations will not help, things will happen to fast. If a fatality is caused and having unmatched tyres is a potential contributory factor would the fact that a tyre fitter said it was OK help with your insurance claim and any Police action.

All manufacturers say fit in sets of 4, some will say it is to maximise sales but they do know a thing or two about tyre safety.

How would you feel if the car spun and killed a child because of unmatched tyres.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - thunderbird

In a FWD car with fronts only, a dab of additional throttle to pull the thing back into line is the correct (if counterintuitive) action to take.

It is a better solution than no winters at all, as long as you remain aware of the limitations and drive accordingly!

How can you drive accordingly, in bad weather you are more likely to be taken by surprise and when that happens with unmatched tyres front and rear tyres being aware of the limitations will not help, things will happen to fast. If a fatality is caused and having unmatched tyres is a potential contributory factor would the fact that a tyre fitter said it was OK help with your insurance claim and any Police action.

All manufacturers say fit in sets of 4, some will say it is to maximise sales but they do know a thing or two about tyre safety.

How would you feel if the car spun and killed a child because of unmatched tyres.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - Smileyman

The fitter at my my local branch of a national tyre chain told me the same at the weekend .. it seems normal for drivers to want only 2 winters fitting ... as I was having my 4 winters from last winter re-fitted.

I think there needs to be better leadership from the professionals .. tyre dealers need to be instructed from HQ about how dangerous this is, and insurance companies need to make it clear the fitting of winters at front or rear only is not allowed and would invalidate the policy (unless as an emergency spare in the event of tyre failure with a maximum speed rating)

The only other way to deal with this is for Police to call it dangerous driving or similar and issue sumonds.

Edited by Smileyman on 07/12/2011 at 23:52

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - dieseldogg

Erm, Thunderbird,

Why would one be taken by surprise? if one was knowingly driving in poor conditions? and if one does not realize conditions are poor, one should not be driving.

I have never yet been "surprised" by poor traction, yes on occassion realizing a fraction too late that I had pushed the envelope a trifle far ,but with the grace of god, moderate skills & perhaps a touch of good fortunate, recovering the situation, but only because I would not "push it" unless it was essentially safe to do so, i.e. that by doing so I was only putting myself at risk?

One should not be "surprised" if one is competent to drive, and is concentrating on driving, as absolutly one should be in poorer conditions.

Or else stay at home.

just a thought

M

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - thunderbird

Erm, Thunderbird,

Why would one be taken by surprise? if one was knowingly driving in poor conditions? and if one does not realize conditions are poor, one should not be driving.

I have never yet been "surprised" by poor traction, yes on occassion realizing a fraction too late that I had pushed the envelope a trifle far ,but with the grace of god, moderate skills & perhaps a touch of good fortunate, recovering the situation, but only because I would not "push it" unless it was essentially safe to do so, i.e. that by doing so I was only putting myself at risk?

One should not be "surprised" if one is competent to drive, and is concentrating on driving, as absolutly one should be in poorer conditions.

Or else stay at home.

just a thought

M

dieseldogg, you are obviously a driving God and we should all look up to you.

How can you seriously say "one should not be surprised if one is competent to drive". In any road condition you can be taken by surprise, there are other drivers on the road plus pedestrains and dogs etc and all can be unpredictable at best, but when grip is limited by snow and ice that surprise and your reaction to it can and will lead to any driver regardless of their ability having what I will describe as a "moment". How serious that moment is will be down to speed and luck (not skill) but if you have less grip on one axle than the other because of the tyres fitted that "moment" will be potentially more serious.

Best of luck, hope we don't meet on the road.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - dieseldogg

As indeed do I!

Touche.

But seriousley, no I am not a driving God, my eyesight is poor, especially at night and I never figgered myself to be a fast driver as I recognised I did not have the requisite skills.

However i do take my driving seriously, which is not to say that I do not occassionally lapse or make mistakes, i.e. momentary inattention.......cor would you look at the body on that!

but so far over 35 years and 700,000 odd thousand miles without a serious accident I can perhaps have some reason for feeling a trifle smug?

I reasonably feel that this is mostly down to defensive driving, i.e. leaving a safe gap in front, planning ahead, consideration for other road users, factoring in road conditions and ones own skill set.

I may well now cause a multiple pile up on the way home, but I'll try not to.

And no I have never been "surprised"...........yet

PS

If you meet me on the road watch out for the light being reflected offen my personal Halo.

Per a reputable tyre fitter that is not a problem - Winter tyres, two only on the front. - madf

I have driven in the past with only two winter tyres on the driven wheels.

Soemtimes in appalling conditions with drifts > height of my car...

In modern traffic and with modern cars and with engines devloping much more power with fat wheels unsuited to snow and ice, I would never do it again..

Like Dog I have drivem for over 47 years and nearly 1 million miles.. BUT I would only drive with 4 winter tyres.. or none.

Since driving in bad weather is optional for me, I don't have winter tyres and sit at home..