Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - ShereKhan
My father is looking to change cars.

He's going to be downsizing from a Rover 620 to one of the following.

Toyota Corolla 1.6 SR 5DR
Citroen C4 1.6 VTS + 5 DR

I've read that the Corolla is to be replaced next year, so I think it may be unwise to go for the Corolla. I'm going to part ex my 306 cabriolet, so far i've been offered anything from 4.2k to 5.2k for my car from various dealers.

The car is going to be used for mainly town journeys and the occasional motorway trip on the M4 Bristol-London.

One Toyota dealer told me to come back to him last to get the best price for cost to change (for a brand new one). He couldn't give me a price for my car as he needed to underwrite the value??

I thought that most dealers used the glass guide to work out value. What I don't understand is how can another value the car when they haven't even seen it!? Or is it a case that Toyota dealer will sell to Peugeot dealer? (Maybe Blue Haddock can elighten me).

I have found plenty of deals for the Citreon (which doesn't suprise me) But I can't find a single deal for the Toyota even though its going to be replaced next year. Unless they are planning on having a massive sale at the end of the year??

So far my father and myself can't work out what to go for (we'll both drive the car) We like both cars so can't work out which will be best over 3 years.

Can anyone offer some advice?

Thanks


--
306 2.0 SE Cabriolet
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - blue_haddock
Plenty of deals available on the corolla - try broker4cars, drivethedeal, ukcarbroker, carfile etc.

Your cabby is probably too old for a main dealer to sell so he will either give you a price that it would fetch at auction or try to get someone to underwrite the car - basically agree to buy it off the dealer at an agreed price.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Red Baron
In general, Toyota appear to make cars that are more reliable than those of Citroen. Full Stop. Of course, there are always exceptions as members of this forum can attest.

If I had to choose between these two cars I would pick the C4. It is newer, better looking, more individual, but those are just my opinions.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
Beautiful yet erratic

or

reliable but dull as dishwater

not an easy choice. We went for the former, but are now on first name terms with the service department of our dealership. We don't regret it, as it is a lovely thing and we couldn't live with the tedium of a Toyota - but that's just us.

Drive both around town, country roads and on the motorway. You'll know yourself what you like more.



Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - ShereKhan
Thanks for all the replies so far - Thanks for the info Blue Haddock. brokers4cars seems to best price so far.

I've managed to find a preregistered car for the same price, however the main dealer in question hasn't replied to my emails and the car is silver in colour (prefer the blue)

My father used to own a Citroen GS in the 70's so likes the Citroen, he has never been keen on Japanese cars. But he now thinks the Corolla looks more european.

However we can't decide between them. May end up choosing a car with straws at this rate...


--
306 2.0 SE Cabriolet
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - P 2501
"we couldn't live with the tedium of a Toyota"

Tedium = car that starts first time every time and doesn't breakdown every week.

I have driven the Corolla (though not the C4) and would never describe it as tedious.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
Tedium is perhaps the wrong word.

The Toyota is like the prince of wales in brown y-front pants. He'll always do the job but won't stir your soul.

The Citroen is like Uma Thurman lacy La Perla underwear - less practical but so stunning you're happy to lose some common sense.
Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - pyruse
Tedium is perhaps the wrong word.

The Toyota is like the prince of wales in brown y-front pants. He'll always do the job but won't stir your soul.

The Citroen is like Uma Thurman lacy La Perla underwear - less practical but so stunning you're happy to lose some common sense.
Lee -- There's no place like 127.0.0.1
-----------------------------

Good grief - it's only a car.
A car is just a means of getting you from point A to point B safely, comfortably and reliably.

If I want to stir my emotions, almost anything is better than a car for doing it.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Happy Blue!
Pyruse

I think that the majority of the people on this site would disagree - which is why we are on here. Otherwise we would all be in Mondeo TDCi's and not BMws, Subarus, and even Focus saloons.


--
Espada III - well if you have a family and need a Lamborghini, what else do you drive?
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
Agree with Espada III entirely.

If we weren't bothered about anything but the A-B then we'd all be driving Nissan Almeras and spend our time more usefully than posting on here :-)

The original question was along the lines of which car to buy - we're trying to differentiate them as best we can.

Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - stevied
Pyruse, why you on this website? : )

Which magazine have a cracking website, I believe there's a lively discussion going on about the merits of which washing machine is the quietest.....

Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Lud
Yeah Pyruse, we don't need a voice of sanity thanks very much. There are quite enough bigots to ensure heated discussion at all times. Sanity is redundant here.

Don't think I've driven a Corolla SR but didn't much like the petrol Corolla I have driven, although it was obviously adequate to its task. Bit wallowy though even on motorway, which is a no-no for me.

C4 VTR+ 1.6, obviously a terrific car. And much better looking.

BTW, why to people give two hoots whether a car is 'European looking' or not? Seems utterly barmy to me.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - stevied
Sanity's for losers!

I was only joking BTW Pyruse.... no offence intended! I can talk, anyway, I get Holiday Which myself.... if anyone wants any tips on top travel insurance deals or how to get your money back from tour operators, I'm your (dull) man!
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - ShereKhan
Lud,
Unfortunately the habits of my 59 year old father cannot be changed - so if he doesn't like it he isn't gonna grow to like it. Whereas I am a lot younger (30) so I open to anything that is different. I'd rather we got a 3dr sports hatch - it carries 5 people however as my parents and their friends are in their 50's/60's+ they find it hard to get in and out of the rear.

I've contacted one of the brokers given by Blue Haddock and have now spoken to the dealer. They have advised that the price has gone up against the brokers price....I'm waiting for a p/x price from them to see what they offer.

Prices so far
Citroen C4 1.6 VTR - 10995
Toyota 1.6 SR - 12078
--
306 2.0 SE Cabriolet
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
SK,

I'm sure you're already aware, but there's a difference between the VTR and the VTR+ you mention in your first post


Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
{re-reads message}

Sorry, scratch that last post of mine, you're on about the VTS which has many more toys and is a bit more £££


Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Pugugly {P}
Toyota by head, Ciroen by Heart.

By the way that 306 of yours is a beautiful motor.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - ShereKhan
Citroënian - sorry I meant VTR+

--
306 2.0 SE Cabriolet
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - pyruse
Agree with Espada III entirely.
If we weren't bothered about anything but the A-B then we'd
all be driving Nissan Almeras and spend our time more usefully
than posting on here :-)


It might amuse you to know that one of our cars is an Almera 1.8.
I have to say it's not in the least boring when you put your foot to the floor, though.
The original question was along the lines of which car to
buy - we're trying to differentiate them as best we can.


Sure - but reliability, comfort, cost of ownership and depreciation seem to me a lot more important than whether your emotions are stirred by driving the thing.

It's the places I drive to and the people I share the journey with in my car that stir my emotions, not the metal box I'm sitting in.

And no offence taken to any of the comments - I was only stirring anyway.
I'm interested in the mechanical side of cars, but I've always been baffled by the emotional attachment some people develop to them (and I'm male and mechanically minded).

Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Lud
Wd you describe yrself as an intelligent car user, pyruse, rather than an 'enthusiast'?

There are many such, people who are quite sensible in the way they drive and look after their cars but don't give much of a stuff for any of it.

There is an element of neurosis or skewed psychology in car enthusiasts.

And of course in the much larger numbers of car owners.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - pyruse
Wd you describe yrself as an intelligent car user, pyruse, rather
than an 'enthusiast'?


I'd describe myself as a mechanically aware car user.
There are many such, people who are quite sensible in the
way they drive and look after their cars but don't give
much of a stuff for any of it.
There is an element of neurosis or skewed psychology in car
enthusiasts.


I'm not going there. Who knows why people get emotional about cars? Not me.
And of course in the much larger numbers of car owners.


Wel, yes, otherwise how would Land Rover ever sell any Freelanders?
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Citroënian {P}
>>It might amuse you to know that one of our cars is an Almera 1.8. I have to say it's not in the least boring when you put your foot to the floor, though.

{Laughing} - that's a bit of a coincidence! Still, I drive a Skoda Fabia that is perhaps even more style-suicide, but if you floor it, it'll disappear and will also do 65mpg with ease.

>>Sure - but reliability, comfort, cost of ownership and depreciation seem to me a lot more important than whether your emotions are stirred by driving the thing.

Citroens have always been about style, (the Saxo-Xsara period aside), and this is often over substance. One makes a conscious decision to compromise if you go for the Citroen - and it's not necessarily a rational choice give then jd power surveys etc. But style does matter to some, even if style to them is a pink smart fortwo or a streetKa.

Lee -- There\'s no place like 127.0.0.1
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Lud
Just wondering, ShereKhan, if the European look of the Corolla has prevailed despite the 2k price difference, or whether the superior dynamics and slick packaging of the C4 have had the right effect?
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - tack
I have had my C4 VTR+ 1.6 diesel (110) since December. Good price from internet dealer, not an import, not pre-reg!

One of the best cars I have had. Comfy, reliable, good kit for money (dual zone climate control, ABS, traction control, cruise control, radio controls on steering wheel, all round elec windows,and mirrors excellent sport seats) nice looking car. Don't see too many on the road.....even in France.

Just come back from France, cruised at 80mph for 5 hours both ways, did over 600 miles whilst there, never put a foot wrong. Only criticism? Douglas Bader would complain about leg room in rear. But hey, I am driving so why would I worry? Also, too harsh over potholes....and I mean harsh!. On motorway though, next to no wind noise or tyre rumble on 17" alloys, smooth as a baby's botty, no diesel clatter.

It will make Dad feel younger as it doesn't come with a Trilby hat or tartan blanket.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - Lud
Did it do 50 mpg?

Great car to drive I thought.
Toyota Corolla SR or Citroen C4 VTR - tack
Did it do 50 mpg?


On a run at 65mph, will do it easy, and better. Steady 80mph got me about 45mpg. Round town, can't get better than 36mpg.

Only done 4000 miles, so engine still tight maybe?