Have you tried driving each one?

C'mon Scot, time to get off the pot. You've been asking about these two models since early Spring on here, Volvoforums and MercedesClub UK and I have already given you several replies! :)

I currently have a 2007 A Class A180 CDi Elegance Auto with 15" wheels (only the Avantgarde model has 16")

My previous car was a 2007 Volvo S40 2.0D SE with 17" wheels.

The Volvo rides better, easily.

Neither cars had suspension changes to the newer models you are looking at. I once tried an S40 with 18" wheels, was OK but was firmer and tended to tramline (i.e. follow the contour of the road)

Avoid R Design or Sport S40s, most of which had firmer suspension.

As far as small cars go however, the previous A Class rides fairly well, and is quite refined with less road noise than others.

Only reason I sold the S40 was I was coming down from 3 cars to 2, and Mrs. 72Dudes has to have an automatic and the earlier diesel A Classes do not have a partical filter. Ideal for my many shortish journeys with the occasional long distance trip.

Edited by 72 dudes on 20/09/2015 at 20:55

Thanks very much 72 dudes. That is the last time I will post. Your detailed and helpful reply really has satisfied even me.

I admit to, and apologise for over researching. Basically I am neurotic and also after surprises (my fault) with my current car I want to make sure I get it right this time.

No more posts on this subject. Thanks again for your patience and reponses much appreciated.

Only meant as a light hearted jibe, not an admonishment!

Feel free to continue asking questions, I'm happy to help.

But there is a danger of over-thinking it!