New (second hand) Car - Opinion - chesterfieldhouse

Would really value forums views on my next motor. l presently have a trusty Seat Alhambra 1.9 PD 2001, with nearly 250K on the clock. Has been reliable & trustworthy, though in the next year or so l'll be looking to change.

l don't really want another people carrier, don't really need one; and l didn't really want an estate (as we have 2 dogs) l really like the Jeep Patriot, though l have heard that parts are very expensive. The only estate that l like & would consider; is the Octavia vRS.

Opinions valued.

New (second hand) Car - Opinion - Peter.N.

I don't know much about new cars as I only run them at 10 years+ as I can still repair those, but I do know that the big Skoda's are very well reported on especially for comfort which is my main concern. I did have a ride in a Skoda taxi a few months ago and was very impressed with that.

If you look at 'Parkers guide' on the net they give a pretty good description of all recent cars so that may help you choose.

You will certainly get a better fuel consumption from and estate than a 4WD.

New (second hand) Car - Opinion - RobJP

I'll throw out what might seem an odd question here : you say possibly the Octavia estate, but only if it's the VRS version. Why ?

The VRS will have the biggest wheels (so less give in the suspension, less comfortable), the hardest suspension (so less give, less comfort), the lowest tyre profile (so less comfortable, and more expensive tyres) ... I struggle to see the benefit in having that version over a 'standard' variant.

I mean, yes, it'll look sporty. But maybe I'm now so old that arriving at my destination without feeling like my back has been beaten by angry dwarves armed with baseball bats actually appeals

New (second hand) Car - Opinion - Peter.N.

I have the same philosophy which is why I have run hydropnumatic Citroens for about the last 30 years and still do. I don't want to go round corners at 60mph or have my spine broken by potholes so the higher tyre profile meaning generally the smallest wheels the better for me, I would go back to crossplies if they were legal. Some of the modern cars have a diabolical ride for what reason, because the big wheels and thin tyres look nice? They remind me of bicycle wheels.

New (second hand) Car - Opinion - chesterfieldhouse

Thank you all for your opinions. Yes, l see your point with the better fuel economy of an estate & not going for the sporty model.

New (second hand) Car - Opinion - bazza

Best to have a good think about what you need the car to do from day to day, rather than just opt on a whim for say a VRS. Do you live half way up a mountain or miles off road, in which case a 4x4 might be useful, although there are far better choices than a Patriot. A VRS is a lovely car, but at its best on well surfaced empty A roads, where it can be driven to its potential by a sporty driver. As ROb says, the low profiles and stiffened suspension will not give the most comfy ride compared to other estates in that range, i have a 1.9 tdi Octavia estate on 15" rims and higher profile tyres, which are cheap and comfortable. The car does the job for me just fine and is never lacking in grip or performance. You can still pick up the old tech 1.9tdi estates which never had a DPF fitted for very sensible money by the way.