Out of these two, you're getting a lot more car for your money with the Mercedes - although the V40 looks overpriced. If you like the Volvo but want the space, you could look at a V60.

Do you need a diesel? If you don't do a high mileage have a look at some petreol versions of these cars.

I thought I remembered from a previous post of yours that you change cars more often than every 5 years: apologies if I've confused you with someone else.

Edited by Avant on 08/06/2014 at 00:19

We'll assume the MB is an auto, a manual MB is a miserable wretch of a thing, and after suffering the hell of one you won't be able to give it away in due course.

We'll also assume the Volvo is a manual, i wouldn't risk a geartronic or whatever its called as a long termer.

MB for me, the Volvo disqualifies itself for long term if its fitted with the devils own electric parking brake of doom.

MB drives the correct wheels too.

MB indy workshop back up is superb, some very good ones out there, Volvo indies are about but much thinner on the ground...for long term ownership good make specific indies are vital.

Do not neglect an MB autobox, oil change every 40k or so and it will last forever.

Edited by gordonbennet on 08/06/2014 at 09:44