Second year running that my Nissan Pulsar 1.6 has failed its MOT on a broken coil spring (different side each time). Roads round our way are terrible these days. What’s the best used sub-£10k pothole proof SUV? I’m sure most of the “soft roaders” out there will be no tougher than my Nissan. I do a very low mileage so not too concerned about fuel consumption but no diesel, please. And would need to be ULEZ compliant, certainly not paying the Khan tax! Suggestions welcome.

Usually best to replace springs in pairs anyway. No such thing as a pothole proof SUV and they are overpriced for what they are so you won't get much for £10k.

Possibly larger off roaders will be more resistant but if petrol to help re ULEZ the cost of fuelling would be eye watering - and again for £10k you'll only get a near sc***yard banger.

My Skoda Superb had a rear spring fail after a few years and a front spring fail the year after. Replaced them all in pairs and the replacements we're still going strong when I sold it after 10 years ownership.

Edited by Big John on 06/05/2025 at 18:19

Good call. I had a 3.0 Outback a few years back, brilliant car.

less sophisticated like a Fiat Tipo

Hmm, that reminds me. Fiat Panda 4x4? and higher profile tyres a good call.

Edited by Big John on 06/05/2025 at 19:35

Maybe a Dacia Duster? They seem quite tough things, presumably with Romanian roads in mind - they may well be better than UK ones by now. It may share some parts with your Nissan being part of the Renault club but others will know. But on sensible tyres I imagine it would be good.

How about a RAV4 petrol.

Well within your budget , 2 or 4Wd . Great reputation for reliabilty as long as you choose the petrol version.

70 profile tyres which can take all the punishment served up on our roads