MINI Cooper D gearbox rattle

In 2012 I bought a new MINI Cooper D. After just 12 weeks of ownership the car developed a rattle when changing gear. The MINI dealer replaced both the gearbox and clutch. Sine 70,000 miles later the car is making the same noise. Do I keep the car or change it? Also the brake pads are only lasting 20,000 miles, is this normal?

Asked on 8 October 2016 by stressed debby

Answered by Honest John
The rattle will be the dual mass flywheel. I'd guess that flywheel and clutch need replacing, not the gearbox. Not a very good life for a DMF and clutch but not bad enough to get free replacements. 20k miles is about average for front brake pads.
Similar questions
My 2013 Ford Focus diesel has developed a knocking sound on the gear change between 1st-2nd-3rd. The car has also started making vibrations through the whole car when at idle speed too, it gets to the...
I own a 2003 Ford Galaxy diesel, which refuses to change gear when the engine is on. Could this be a faulty clutch?
My 2011 Vauxhall Insignia has developed the known problem of the whine in the gearbox, signifying it's inevitable demise. Vauxhall has agreed to replace, 'as a good will gesture' as the vehicle has done...
Related models
Great performance from Cooper S, much smoother and more sophisticated than first generation, capable of travelling distances in comfort.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car