Comparison of 2 new estates - any known problems? | Ask Honest John

Comparison of 2 new estates - any known problems?

Looking two models (2016 Vauxhall Astra ST SRi 1.4 150 V 2016 Skoda Octavia Estate se 1.4 150) for 6K annual mileage with a high proportion of short journeys & plan to keep for 8 years+. Have read exhaustively all the tests & reviews, etc. Are there any known mechanical or other problems with either? Is either demonstrably more reliable? Are either of these cars tyres too low profile for comfort? Am thinking of using UK Car Discount or maybe Carwow to purchase. Before I road test, your comments, as ever, would be most welcome.

Asked on 18 August 2016 by ridgerog

Answered by Honest John

The is the newer EA211 belt cam engine in the Skoda, so it will need a fresh timing belt, tensioner and waterpump after 4 years for which you need to allow £500-£600. But it's lovely to drive. The Astra is chain cam so unless the tensioner or waterpump fails (and I've never heard of this) you save that expense. The Skoda feels the more solid car. The Astra has more sophisticated suspension and ultimately handles better.

Tags: buying family estate

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:

Similar questions

Fear of high mileage

I have decided on a Mazda 6 2.2d SL 185 estate and have now found one locally. It's an 0-plate9 one owner ( ex lease ) with FMSH and 96K on the clock at £7495. I am bothered about the high mileage....

£5k estate also suitable for smaller driver

I'm looking to replace our 2000 Ford Focus 1.8 Zetec estate. The Focus is perfect for me but my wife who is 5'1" tall finds it difficult to reach the pedals. She tried a mark II Focus and the position...

A large family car - what do you suggest?

We are looking for a used estate or 4x4/Crossover. My husband is 6'5 and we need to be able to fit a baby seat behind him, which we currently struggle to do in our Jaguar X-type estate. Leg room is the...