What's wrong with our SEAT Alhambra's gearbox?

We have an '02 plate SEAT Alhambra 1.9TDI. In the last month or so, my wife has lost power twice when driving it. She switched the engine off, and everything was fine again. In the first few days, we were concerned that 'something' was noisy at low speed - initially I thought loose plastic engine cowling vibrating - as small blip on the accelerator seems to make everything run smoothly. It also seemed very 'crunchy' when manoeuvring at slow speed.

We were driving to the the local garage when I could also hear a metallic rattle from the engine bay (sounded similar to rattle you get when one of the suspension springs breaks and sits in the cups). The garage checked everything for loose bolts but could find nothing. They decided to test drive it and the car lost all transmission. They have diagnosed a gearbox issue and suggested it may be a common fault on the 6-speed boxes - a weak rivet? Is this right and, if so, is it likely to be fixable without recourse to a new gearbox, or a gearbox specialist?

Asked on 31 July 2010 by AndyI

Answered by Honest John
Yes, these gearboxes have a nasty habit of self-destructing. It's covered in the Audi A3 and Volkswagen Golf entries in car-by-car breakdown at HJUK. An Altea uses the same components.
Similar questions
I own a 1998 Volkswagen Golf. Last week, while changing gear, the car has started to make a whining noise. Any ideas what this could be?
I've been told by my VW mechanic that my 51 plate Golf mk 5 is making a whirling noise that is coming from the main shaft bearing, and would need a gearbox remove and strip. Is the noise something serious...
I'm thinking of buying a car to use as a taxi. I've noticed a lot of drivers use the Skoda Octavia. I was prepared to buy a 2004 diesel model when a mate of mine who is in the trade told me they suffer...
Related models
True seven-seater with more cheerful trim than its VW Sharan and Ford Galaxy equivalents. Good car-like drive.
Roomy cabin with a decent boot. Distinctive styling. Excellent crash test rating.

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer