Which Porsche will depreciate the least?

I am thinking of committing a large amount of cash (for me) on a special car to enjoy in my retirement. Which of the following three cars which I am considering is likely to retain the most value over a period of ownership of probably at least five years, with fairly light use?

I am trying to choose between a 2015 Cayman 2.7, a 2013 Boxster S and a 2010 997 Gen 2 911 Carrera. Each one is priced similarly. All have less than 5000 miles on the clock and are literally "as new"; all have the PDK gearbox. I think the 911 is probably the safest investment, though it's only a fairly basic specification, unlike the others. Which would you recommend?

Asked on 26 May 2016 by rw jersey

Answered by Honest John
Depends totally on whether you like driving in the summer with the top down, in which case it's the Boxster S, assuming it's the facelift Boxster 988 and not an older late reg 987. Otherwise I don't see much point in the Cayman v/s the 911.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
In early 2013, I bought a new BMW 640d M Sport Gran Coupe. I part exchanged it two years later for a new BMW M4. That cost me £32,000 in depreciation. I'm now thinking of selling my M4 at the three year...
Thinking about buying a small electric car for my wife. She does mainly local trips, shopping, visiting friends, absolute maximum 70 - 80 miles in a day. I know new electric cars are expensive and suffer...
I'm looking for a cheap to run car which will be reliable, but over the magic 100,000 mark, as I do plenty of miles and don't want to crucify value. Ideally for about £2500. I do enough miles (12,000 plus)...
Related models
All-new Boxster is lighter and more economical. Returns a claimed 36mpg. Good looking redesigned interior. Even better to drive than before.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car