Boxster or F-Type?

I'm planning to trade in my 2006 Boxster (40k, FSH) in the new year and am undecided between a 981 Boxster or F-type convertible. My budget is around £30k plus the trade-in, so I'm looking at manufacturer approved used. My annual mileage is only about 3k. Insurance and tax on either are roughly the same. The car will be garaged and used purely for leisure. Which would you go for?

Asked on 30 December 2015 by Daniel Joseph

Answered by Honest John
3k miles a year including a lot of short runs is very bad indeed for a flat 6 Porsche, though if all your runs are at least 50 miles that's okay. You're used to Porsche handling. An F-Type roadster doesn't handle with such alacrity, and has virtually no luggage space at all, but it's still a wonderful car. Try to get an extended test drive in one. (You can actually hire them at Schiphol airport, but I can't remember which rental company.)
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
Hi HJ & Team. A question regarding our legal rights. We bought, approximately a month ago, a 2006 Ford Fusion 1.4TDCi Zetec with about 70k miles on the clock. We paid approximately £2,200 less a £500...
Dear John, my friend, who doesn't have a computer, is a professional dog walker and business is good. He wonders if it's possible to buy, at auction or otherwise, an ex-police dog patrol van or similar,...
I recently spotted a nearly new approved used car at a local dealer on the BMW UK website which was exactly what I was after. It was advertised as available, not as "coming soon", so I assumed it would...
Related models
All-new Boxster is lighter and more economical. Returns a claimed 36mpg. Good looking redesigned interior. Even better to drive than before.
Stylish and highly desirable open top two-seater with stunning looks. Better to drive than the XK. Incredible sound. All-wheel drive versions are grippier and no less fun

Value my car