Do I really need to change the dual-mass flywheel?

My 2004 Renault Scenic is due to have its clutch replaced and my local mechanic has recommended I replace the dual-mass fly wheel at the same time. Is this really necessary or is he trying to get more money out of me?

Asked on 27 November 2013 by Lily

Answered by Honest John
Pretty stupid not to because the huge cost of this job is separating the engine and gearbox, so while it's apart it's better to replace everything in between.
Similar questions
I own a 2010 Audi A1 diesel. During a recent service, I was told it needs a new clutch and dual-mass flywheel. I have been experiencing recently that sometimes when shifting gears it gets stiff, or sometimes...
I have a 2010 Nissan Qashqai+2. Last August after a problem I took it to my local garage and they said that there was a problem with the flywheel base plate, which was very unusual and it would need replacing...
I have an ongoing problem with the clutch on my Golf. It is okay at start-up but after driving for about 10 miles there is no pressure at all and pedal sticks to floor. It will not pump back up, and...
Related models
Far better than the previous model. The Grand model seats seven. Practical and versatile. Excellent crash test rating.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car