Dream car or Budget, which comes first? Tell us your thoughts | No thanks

Which new car offers reliability, good fuel economy and space for passengers?

I am looking to buy a new car but am totally confused at the moment. I want a car with performance, good handling and comfort. My wife and I also need something with all-round ability, shopping journeys of just a few miles, touring holidays and also comfortable space in the back for two adults plus our grandson of six months. I quite like the look of the new Mazda CX-5 but I'm not sure about the claimed MPG. I'm also confused as to whether I should buy a diesel vehicle (I have concerns about the DPF) or petrol, or even be looking for a hybrid vehicle. Fuel economy is important and a decent sound system is also a must. My budget is approximately £25,000. Can you help?

Asked on 28 July 2012 by DB, Retford

Answered by Honest John
I was driving the CX-5 again over the last couple of days. The 2WD petrol model gave about 38-39mpg and the 4WD high-power diesel model gave about 42mpg, while the 4WD high-power diesel automatic gave around 40mpg. You'll probably get similar economy from a Nissan Qashqai 1.6DCI 130 and there are no worries over DPFs with this or with the Mazda because of their fast-warm engine systems. I personally still rate the Mazda 5 1.6d TS2 on 205/55 R16 Toyo J48 tyres better for ride and handling, and mine averaged 48.1mpg over 11,000 miles.
Similar questions
I live in the countryside and drive 250 miles a week to the office and back, mostly on B-roads, and also use the car for the usual things, including travelling by motorway to visit friends around the country,...
I was interested in your warning about impending failures of diesel particulate filters and dual mass flywheels on diesel engined cars. My Freelander 2 is now two and a half years old. Do I part-exchange...
I'm looking to replace both a 54-plate 2.0-litre automatic petrol Ford Mondeo and a 2007 1.4-litre manual Fiesta with a newer Mondeo, which will cover 8000 to 10,000 miles a year. I've noticed that you...
Related models
Very comfortable front seats with good ride. Feels well built. Strong Renault sourced dCi diesels. Elevated driving position and good visibility.
Economical and efficient. Comfortable ride. Well equipped as standard. Practical and spacious yet compact.

Ask Honest John

Value my car