Should I replace my Ford Focus with something more economical?

I have only managed a maximum 35.5mpg from my Focus 1.6 at best, using BP Ultimate petrol. If I achieve 35mpg constantly, would you suggest just keeping the car? I can spend £3500 on a new car. I used the mpg calculator and, if I bought a car that did 50mpg instead of 32-33mpg, I would save roughly £900, which is quite a lot.

Asked on 14 July 2012 by KC, via email

Answered by Honest John
Yes, but if you bought a diesel on your budget you'd have to reckon on a new dual mass flywheel (£1200), new diesel particulate filter (£1200), new turbo (£1200) and new EGR (£600), all possibly within a year. Doesn't add up, does it?
Similar questions
My wife and I have identical Ford Focus 1.8 Zetec diesels, one four and one two years old, and we often swap. The tyres are the same make and same pressure, and both are fully serviced. After extensive...
I recently bought a Ford Focus Powershift diesel and the garage quoted Ford figures of 47-62mpg. It only ever reaches 40mpg. If I had been told this initially I would never have bought it. I feel I have...
I am looking to buy a small petrol car which has a big range. I have family who live in Currie, Edinburgh, approximately 400 miles away from where I live. I am looking for a small car that can do this...
Related models
Much improved 2004 Focus. Great to drive. Comfortable and well laid-out interior. Wide range of engines. Low emission ECOnetic versions offer 55mpg +.