Dream car or Budget, which comes first? Tell us your thoughts | No thanks

Which Citroen would make a good replacement for the discontinued Xsara Picasso?

My second Xsara Picasso diesel will be three years old in late March. Sadly, they don't make it any longer and the other Citroen offerings either seem too big, too small or resemble a glazed van. What can I go for? The diesel gives an average fuel economy of 60mpg, and the three collapsible and removable rear seats make it an ideal load carrier. The size is just nice for the garage, for the country lanes of Norfolk and also gives an non-claustrophobic interior. Any suggestions?

Asked on 21 April 2012 by LD, Hethersett, Norfolk

Answered by Honest John
The current Berlingo is about twice as strong and three times safer in a crash than the original. I watched them following each other down the production line and it was like a biscuit tin followed by a tank. The new Berlingo also rides and handles vastly better, and better than many other cars. So don't dismiss it as a glazed van too quickly.
Similar questions
I am looking for an MPV that is economical to run as a daily use car (school run, work, holidays), can be used as an occasional camper or in which the seats fold flat to form a double bed, and the seats...
My wife has a 2003 2.0-litre diesel Peugeot Partner Combi, which has been an excellent multi-purpose workhorse especially as an incredible load-carrier, mainly due to its internal height and huge capacity...
My 2006 Renault Scenic Dynamique at 50,000 miles is due for a change. Could you suggest a suitable replacement? It needs to be able to carry two touring bikes inside, standing with the front wheels removed....
Related models
Practical and versatile family transport that's cheap to buy and run, lots of carrying capacity with individual folding rear seats.
Cheap to buy, spacious cabin with three full size seats across the back, comfortable cruiser, aerodynamic shape means 1.6 HDi can do 55mpg.

Ask Honest John

Value my car