Does BP Ultimate diesel compare to Shell V-Power?

You confirmed last week that Shell V-Power diesel has advantages over ordinary diesel in terms of particulates and improved performance. I similarly use BP Ultimate diesel in the expectation that it should help the particulate filter in my new style Ford KA 1.3 TDCi to last longer and also appreciate the excellent performance. Am I right in assuming that the two brands are broadly comparable?

Asked on 28 April 2012 by CT, Bexley

Answered by Honest John
I get slightly better mpg out of BP Ultimate diesel, but V-Power diesel has the best lubricity (I've had this confirmed by petrochemists).
Similar questions
My daughter has bought a three year old Isuzu pickup truck with only 12,000 miles on the clock. The DPF light keeps coming on, the main dealer says that this is normal because it shows that the regeneration...
I stumbled across a couple of issues which seem to do the rounds on various forums, so I thought I'd ask here for a definite answer. One is that the Start-Stop mechanism, as implemented in the Audi A6...
The emissions fix was done on my 2010 Volkswagen Golf 1.6 TDI in January 2017 and it now drives very differently. The DSG gearbox changes up into seventh gear much earlier than before (at around 40mph)...
Related models
Easy to drive and economical. Based on the Fiat 500 but handles much better. More room in rear than 500.

Ask Honest John

Value my car