Transmission failure repair followed by head hasket failure - suspicious.

I own a Volvo XC70 and have done 185,000 miles trouble free. A noise recently occurred which became worse and was diagnosed as a failure of the transmission. The remedy was to replace it at a cost of £2500 at a transmission specialist recommended by the dealer.

A wheel bearing was also replaced. The car was returned to me with a leak, which was transmission fluid. This was fixed and the car again returned to me. On the day of return, I immediately noticed a small oil leak, which got worse very quickly.

I took it back into the dealer and was told that the head gasket has gone and will cost almost £3000 to replace. I am also told that this has nothing to do with the transmission repair and is a 'coincidence'.

I am clearly unhappy about the situation where a car goes in with one problem and comes back with another one having shown no symptoms of this whatsoever. It seems to be extremely suspicious.

I am in discussion with the dealership about the situation, but they are not budging. Where do I stand on this? Should I expect to pay for some or all of the head gasket repair?

Asked on 9 April 2013 by RA Shropshire

Answered by Honest John
A head gasket failure can have as much to do with a transmission replacement as a twisted ankle does with brain surgery.
Similar questions
I had the head gasket on my Peugeot Boxer changed, but on the way home (after about five miles) it decided to lose power and cut out. No lights came on the dashboard, it just went dead. After a couple...
The fan in my car isn't working properly. The temperature of the car is going up to 100 degrees and it only cools down when I put the interior fans on hot. Also, I checked the input pipe and the water...
Does a creamy substance on the oil cap indicate head gasket problems?
Related models
Smart-looking 4WD estate with more off-road ability than the previous XC70. Comfortable, safe and practical.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer