Shear and shear alike

My five year old 56,000 mile Porsche C4S recently had a routine service at the local official Porsche centre, where it has always been serviced. In the course of replacing spark plugs, a heat shield needed to be removed from the exhaust. A technician sheared off a bolt attaching the heat shield. The dealer denied responsibility and blamed the age of the vehicle and corrosion. The engine will need to be removed to drill out and replace the bolt, at an estimated cost of over £1,500. In addition the dealer will not rule out further cost being incurred in this process. What is my legal position in this matter?

Asked on 9 August 2011 by DG, via email

Answered by Honest John
One of those things. A garage cannot be held responsible for a rusted bolt shearing while it is doing a routine job.
Similar questions
In the privileged position of contemplating a 997.2 GT3 RS or a 991.2 GT3 touring. Obviously manual linkages are my thing having owned a string of manual 911s over the years and my current pdk equipped...
I've recently purchased a low mileage and fairly mint Porsche 911, 997 manual. However, there is a slight starting problem, sometimes it turns over a couple of times and then stops, turn the key off and...
My father, brother and I are looking to buy a sports car mainly for weekend driving. We are looking to spend around £25,000- £35,000 (maximum) and are looking at Porsche 911 997s and even some 996s. We...
Related models
Quick, sharp and fun yet also docile in traffic, comfortable and comparatively practical.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer