The cam belt in our Chevrolet Tacuma broke after a service - should I involve Motor Codes?

In September last year we had a 40,000-mile service on our Chevrolet Tacuma. The Chevrolet garage we bought it from and always go to advised me to get the cam belt replaced, which I agreed to. On 1 January our engine failed because the tensioner pulley broke, making the cam belt slip and causing extensive damage to the engine. We had to pay (under protest) for the car to be fixed because we need it, but we don't feel responsible because from all the advice and information I've got since this happened, the garage should have replaced the whole kit, not just the belt.

They are claiming Chevrolet’s policy is to change the belt only, but this is a Daewoo engine known to have tensioner failure problems. Trading Standards say I have a good case as they didn't exercise "reasonable care and skill" with our car and advised me to complain to Motor Codes Ltd, which I am about to do. If that doesn't work, T.S. told me to take the Chevrolet garage to court. Do you think we have been treated unfairly? We are £700 out of pocket and now we don't feel like we can trust our car.

Asked on 23 February 2011 by RB, Beccles, Suffolk

Answered by Honest John
Unfortunately you can't do both. By the act of using Motor Codes you automatically appoint Motor Codes as conciliators and arbitrators, so if they leave you high and dry your only remaining option is to complain about your treatment by Motor Codes to the OFT. Motor Codes has been strangely reticent about revealing any details of cases submitted to it and I have no reports from readers, either good or bad. I hope that Motor Codes will come clean with some case histories in the near future and engender some trust from the public.
Similar questions
I first emailed you in June 2011 and lastly in Feb 2012 regarding a broken cambelt on my Audi A6 Avant 2.5TDI quattro and the repair work needed thereafter. To remind you, Chingford Audi neglected to change...
Recently my Vauxhall Zafira went from being a superb gearbox to a bag of nuts in the palm of my hand. The only gears I had were third and fourth. I got relayed to a local garage, and when they looked at...
My car went into a local garage for a replacement radiator. When I collected the car the air conditioning wasn't working and the next day a coolant warning light came on. I took the car back to the garage...