Should I buy a PHEV, electric or petrol?

My existing car is 19 years old and needs replacing. At 2000 miles a year I think electric can be ruled out? PHEV - read this mileage might wear battery down quickly. So should I replace with petrol car?

Asked on 27 February 2026 by Anne

Answered by David Ross
With a very low mileage such as this, an electric car may be a good option as long as you can charge it at home. Without the need to cover long distances, you could go long periods without needing to charge at all and the fewer charge and discharge cycles that occur, the longer the vehicle's drive battery will last. However, charging at home is important to maximise the cost benefits, so we would suggest comparing the running costs of electric versus the other options. A plug-in hybrid would allow you to make short journeys on electric power, but again this is only advantageous if you charge at home. A petrol car would be cheaper to buy than an equivalent electric or hybrid but these are currently hard to buy: www.honestjohn.co.uk/advice/car-buying-advice/why-.../
Similar questions
I currently have a hybrid SUV and I was looking at a replacement. Looking at same car from the same dealer (both demonstrators) the hybrid was significantly more expensive than the electric for same spec/year....
I really don't like the idea of buying an electric powered car. I have seen articles from some quite major companies who have made a hydrogen engine. Why would they go to the expense of doing that if they...
We’ve got around £15k to spend on a second car, mostly for city centre/local journeys. We have a charging point already but unsure whether to buy a used electric or petrol? We are considering a Peugeot...