Time to cut my losses?
Sorry - got a 2 part question for you:
Part 1
I've spent £1,000 on my 52 Reg 60,000 mile 307SW 1.6 SE in the last 12 months fixing electrical and suspension problems (BSR unit, washer pump, front wishbones after bushing wore, top mounts).
I'm still left with a knocking / rattle which my local mechanic wants to change the front shocks for (he's looked at everything else), so I'm faced with another bill for £250. I need a new set of tyres and I guess the clutch will be due soon.
Facing reliability problems which are pushing up running costs, is it time to cut my losses and trade in for a different second hand car? Or have I just had an unlucky run and I should keep hold of it for another couple of years to get my money back on the investment in repairs?
Part 2 of the question:
The car itself has been great for the family, versatile seating and good load carrying for a mid-size estate and a pretty good drive, if a little under-powered. Can you recommend a replacement mid-size estate , perhaps something with better reliability?
Part 1
I've spent £1,000 on my 52 Reg 60,000 mile 307SW 1.6 SE in the last 12 months fixing electrical and suspension problems (BSR unit, washer pump, front wishbones after bushing wore, top mounts).
I'm still left with a knocking / rattle which my local mechanic wants to change the front shocks for (he's looked at everything else), so I'm faced with another bill for £250. I need a new set of tyres and I guess the clutch will be due soon.
Facing reliability problems which are pushing up running costs, is it time to cut my losses and trade in for a different second hand car? Or have I just had an unlucky run and I should keep hold of it for another couple of years to get my money back on the investment in repairs?
Part 2 of the question:
The car itself has been great for the family, versatile seating and good load carrying for a mid-size estate and a pretty good drive, if a little under-powered. Can you recommend a replacement mid-size estate , perhaps something with better reliability?
Asked on 16 May 2011 by roginyorks
Answered by
Honest John
Get rid. Get a newer 307SW or a 308SW. They are the only 7 forward facing seat station wagons. Otherwise you need to go to an MPV, like a Honda FR-V which has 6 forward facing seats. Just avoid the 1.7 engine.
Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.
The Good Garage GuideSimilar questions
I purchased a BMW 645i from a BMW main dealer in May 2005. It has been maintained by them ever since at the required intervals. Recently I have just had the car into the garage and have ended up with a...
My 2003 2000 Mondeo has done 102,000 miles and has been excellent throughout. Recently it started to "pink" and struggle to pull away in higher gears without jerking. After a couple of weeks to eliminate...
I hope you find this interesting and can help me understand my own numbers. I currently have 2003 Renault Scenic 1.6v Fidji, I've driven it since new and bought it off a friend at the end of 3 year lease...
Related models
.jpg?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Makes sense of the 307. Up to seven forward-facing seats. Good to drive. Decent diesels.
Elsewhere on 
.jpg)
