Estaters quo

I have a 2002 Mercedes E430 Avantgarde auto Estate, mileage now 175,000. I have owned the car since new and do not have any finance outstanding. I have always serviced the car with Mercedes. My car is in pretty good nick considering its age. I mailed you in 2006 and in 2008 on the subject of changing the car and you recommended holding onto it, which I have done. The new Mercedes E class Estate (the one that arrived in February) looks pretty interesting. There appears to be a diesel and a petrol version. The 250 and 350 engine sizes would be my preference. So do you think now is the time to swap my car for the new Mercedes E Class? If I did swap, which should I get: either 250 or 350, petrol or diesel? Failing the new Mercedes what other cars would you recommend?

Asked on 24 July 2010 by ED, via email

Answered by Honest John
Though undeniably popular where I live (not far from MB World) I don’t find the new W212 E Class as good looking as the previous W211. An alternative is the new BMW F11 530D Touring, video tested here on 4 door saloon format, that is as good looking as its predecessor was a bit weird: www.honestjohn.co.uk/news/road-tests/bmw/bmw-f10-5...s
Similar questions
I am not sure whether to buy a used Audi 2.0 litre 140 TDI or a 2.0 TFSI, around 70k miles. I am aware that the diesel will give more mpg but as I will not be doing much mileage, I wondered what your views...
We just had a baby and with my wife we would like to buy a new estate, preferably the Audi A4 Avant, although also considering the BMW 3 series touring. With the Audi there seems to be better deals and...
I am following a Dec 2005, Merc 320CDI estate, auto on eBay. This has a full MB dealer history fully documented, two professional owners and despite the high mileage of 181,000 really looks like new in...
Related models
Huge and useful boot space. Well-built and solid interior. Comfortable long distance cruiser. Excellent diesels. Very refined.