Chattering Class

I have owned a series of S-Class Mercedes. At least ten in a row, all wonderful, and all petrol. Recently, against my better judgement, I bought an ex-demonstrator diesel: a S320 CDI LWB, with 9,000 miles on the clock. It's not as smooth as the petrol ones but I can live with that because its fuel consumption is so much better. It's a lovely car but it has one fault/characteristic that is driving me mad. When it starts from cold it makes a metallic whirring or chattering sound (best described as like a cage full of budgies). It's pronounced and though it very much subsides when the engine is warmed up, perhaps after half a mile or so, I can still hear it faintly. All the time. It seems to be when the engine is under light load. The local Mercedes dealer has been endlessly patient but even the workshop foreman reckons he can't hear it. He has tried it from stone cold, and I have also been out with him in the car to reproduce it but he still is at a loss. I can't believe Mercedes send out S classes sounding like this. I know that diesels have an underlying growl that petrol doesn't have (our E Class is petrol and is quieter overall) but this just sounds wrong. What do you think it is? And apart from chopping the car in against a petrol version (a ruinously expensive step), what can I do?

Asked on 24 July 2010 by JM, via email

Answered by Honest John
Diesels have an underlying rattle because they are compression ignition engines. MB does all sorts of things to dampen this down, including a massive cover filled with some sort of foam rubber over the engine itself. I wonder if in your case this might have come a bit loose. Or the engine undertray may have come undone at one of its fixing points. Or a turbo or cat converter heat shield has come loose. Alternatively the noise may be one of the belt driven ancillaries such as the alternator, power steering pump or air-conditioning pump.
Similar questions
My Mk5 Volkswagen Golf, with hybrid stage two turbo, was making a whistling noise. It's now stopped and won't restart, plus lost all oil. The exhaust shows signs of oil in end pipes. What could this be?
I can hear an intermittent ticking after using my 2000 Daewoo Lanos. It carries on after locking the car and has gone on for at least 12 hours.
My Audi Q3 140 TDI is four and a half years old, with a full five year Audi warranty. It has developed a low clatter, at about 2000rpm and noticeable particularly when the engine isn't up to full temperature,...
Related models
Wonderfully luxurious. High-class cabin. Superb refinement on the move. The best looking saloon this size. Improved again from 2010.