all / any - Engine oil - hillspecial

Why is engine oil so much money?

Is it taxed like pertol and diesel ?

Even if it is taxed teh same, should engine oil not retail at about £1.10 per litre / £6 tops for 5 litre bottle.

How much profit is there on the stuff?

all / any - Engine oil - RobJP

You seem to think engine oil is basically 'oil'. Like the stuff they pump out of the ground.

You could not be more wrong.

I used to work in engine oil development. When a new oil was being trialled, the standard was for 10 cars brand-new cars to be extensively tested for power and torque, then to be driven for 100,000 miles each, and then completely re-tested to see what drop in power/torque. Followed by complete engine stripdowns and rebuilds.

So a lot of costs in testing oils. And that doesn't include any of the development costs.

all / any - Engine oil - gordonbennet

Rob's the oil man, all i know is that if you look around and buy it carefully when its on offer its remarkable value.

My last 2 buys have been 4x5 litres Morris 5W40 full synthetic @ £60 delivered, and earlier this week 25 litres Millers Trident same spec turned up @ £80 delivered.

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

I'd be interested to know which brand/s Rob would recommend. I've used various brands from Comma through to Mobil over the years.

I've bought those 25 litres drums of Millers 5w40 before, Great value just fiddly to decant unless you buy a tap for it.

all / any - Engine oil - Avant

It's very gratifying that there are so many people with real expertise and/or experience on this forum - unlike some other forums where most posters are of the barrack-room lawyer variety. Thanks, Rob and GB.

Clearly this must be a different Morris - otherwise one could have visions of ancient oil drums that have been lying around somewhere since the days of the Morris Commercial lorries and vans.....

all / any - Engine oil - gordonbennet

Clearly this must be a different Morris - otherwise one could have visions of ancient oil drums that have been lying around somewhere since the days of the Morris Commercial lorries and vans.....

That 5 gallon brass can of HD 30 made (distilled lovingly) in 1961 will be OK for my fleet won't it Avant..:-)

www.morrislubricantsonline.co.uk/

Edited by gordonbennet on 24/10/2015 at 01:03

all / any - Engine oil - John F

It's very gratifying that there are so many people with real expertise and/or experience on this forum

If only that were true. It seems to me there are only a very few, of advanced years, and who have not kept up with modern developments. How many of them have a basic MechEng degree, let alone honours?

The absurd analogy of synthetic versus real steak illustrates my point beautifully.

all / any - Engine oil - RobJP

Go on then John. Your entire background for saying "huge service intervals are wonderful" seems to rest on your ownership of a TR7. Lets hear about your extensive expertise and qualifications ...

all / any - Engine oil - John F

Go on then John. Your entire background for saying "huge service intervals are wonderful"

I have never said that.

Although my (Russel grp) uni degrees are not in engineering, 'A' level science (I have chemistry and physics) is sufficient to distinguish between the sense and nonsense written on this site. Chemicals and micro-organisms denature oil (greybeards will recall the unforgettable stench in the wake of a decomposing damp old engine). But modern engines are virtually a sealed unit and the relatively uncontaminated oil has a shelf life probably as long as the Angostura bitters in my drinks cupboard (unknown, probably last century).

I still contend that to advise an OAP to change their oil & filter after 365days and 4,000m in their 8yr old 60,000m car is ott. It is of no consequence to them if the engine might only last 125,000m rather than 250,000m. Indeed, such is modern quality that it would probably last to 100,000 if you merely keep it topped up and only renew the filter every 10,000m. Naturally, those with a vested interest in this work will disagree.

all / any - Engine oil - Andrew-T

<< Indeed, such is modern quality that it would probably last to 100,000 if you merely keep it topped up and only renew the filter every 10,000m >>

I have some sympathy with John F's refusal to be bound by the 10K/1 year mantra, but I also feel that it may be mistaken to believe that 'quality' inexorably improves with modernity. OAPs are also commonly heard muttering the famous phrase 'they don't make it like they used to' about all sorts of things. Oil makers have various reasons for changing the spec of their products, some of which may conflict with making the oil last longer.

Also speaking as one with an advanced chemistry degree, I realise that a hydrocarbon subjected to prolonged heat and shearing action in an oxidising environment will not last indefinitely. I decide when to change my oil (in a petrol engine at any rate) mainly by its colour.

Edited by Andrew-T on 25/10/2015 at 11:01

all / any - Engine oil - Smileyman

Wilkinsons are selling oil at £4 a litre, or £3 if you buy a 5 litre bottle (£15) ... the bottle says it meets the speciification, I have not used it yt but will be soom, presumably someone else makes it for them but I don't know whom (I think it is the semi-synthetic oil, best check for yourself if it's a critical aspect)

Edited by Smileyman on 24/10/2015 at 01:06

all / any - Engine oil - RobJP

I wouldn't hugely recommend any particular brand of oil, only to say that to make sure it's not some ridiculously cheap brand that you've never heard of.

Same for fully synthetic / part synthetic / mineral oils. Much as I hate to say it, but it really doesn't make much difference. Synthetic oils are pretty much essential in jet engines, but piston engines it really doesn't make a lot of difference.

Make of all the marketing for synthetic oils what you will. Would you view a synthetic steak as being of higher quality than one from a cow ?

Buy quality, buy the correct grade for your car (or very close to it), and you won't go far wrong.

Whilst I used to work for Shell at Stanlow/Runcorn in oil development (there, think that's the first time I've actually said who I worked for), I'm personally a fan of Castrol. But Morris are also a highly rated brand, especially in industry, industrial machinery and farming/construction equipment.

However, (and I'll appreciate Avant might want to lock the thread after this!) the most critical point is to change your oil and filter regularly. Annually or every 10k miles (whichever is first) is a good balance between continually spending on your car OR leaving it too long, where the oil can start to degrade and not protect your engine sufficiently.

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

Same for fully synthetic / part synthetic / mineral oils. Much as I hate to say it, but it really doesn't make much difference. Synthetic oils are pretty much essential in jet engines, but piston engines it really doesn't make a lot of difference.

How much difference is there between a hydrocracked mineral oil and a PAO synthetic?

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

I still have a good stock of cheap oil I bought from Halfords last Christmas, They were selling halfords own brand oils at £10 for 4litres and with the extra discount it made it £9 plus free delivery. It is produced for Halfords by Comma.

I probably wouldn't use it in anything nice but, It is OK for the Astra.

all / any - Engine oil - gordonbennet

I've told this tale before but here's as good a point as any to float it again.

Some years ago i bought a rather nice (well if you like that sort of thing, i do) low mileage Landcruiser, last of the 70 series with the 3.0td 4 cyl engine still in use in d4d form now.

First thing i did was my own full service, won't name the make of oil but its a current household name found on many shelves, it was their correct spec Diesel specific oil of the time.

Anyway all good but after about a thousand miles the engine didn't sound quite how it did before the rumbling sounds of mains and possibly big ends to my worried ears.

I toddled off down to the Toyota dealer which wasn't a glass palace at the time, mechanic came out and listened to the rumbles and pronounced my increasing fears of full engine rebuild time, gulp.

However i wanted a second opinion so drove gently over to the now sadly gone independent Toyota dealer that was at Collyweston nr Stamford (another housing estate), the mechanic there used to build off road special and overland rally Landcruisers based on my chassis, and knew them inside so why i didn't go there first i can't recall, maybe found out about him after visiting the Toyota dealer.

He came out, gave the engine some welly and told me in colourful terms to drain the xxxx carp out of the sump and put some proper oil in, which i duly did, and that engine never missed a beat and sounded as sweet as can be for the many years i owned it, even after it was written off...another story there...the chap who bought it and put it back on the road contacted me and waxed lyrical about just how sweet the engine was.

What amazed was how quickly this particular oil had degraded, never known it happen before or since like that, maybe it was a duff batch, wrongly packaged, maybe even counterfiet (suppose it happens?), looking back maybe i should have contacted the maker and allowed them to invesigate.

Edited by gordonbennet on 24/10/2015 at 12:18

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

Very interesting story GB, Reminds me a little of the time I had a fuel pump fail and it was leaking petrol into the engine oil and watering it down. Being years ago the car had an oil pressure gauge and I picked up on the low oil pressure quickly enough. such was the joys of engine mounted Solex type fuel pumps.

all / any - Engine oil - gordonbennet

Being years ago the car had an oil pressure gauge and I picked up on the low oil pressure quickly enough.

The good old oil pressure gauge, every car should have one and water temp.

My Benz has one but it's a rare thing to find these days, i'd be very interested to see the oil pressure at a hot tickover when the oils been in for some 20k miles on extended abuse servicing, then what it runs at after an oil change and back up to temp.

all / any - Engine oil - Simon
Go on then, at least give us a clue as to who's oil this was...
all / any - Engine oil - brum

Does it begin with C and end with an L ?

all / any - Engine oil - jc2

Why are so many people worried about saving two pence/litre on oil having spent thousands of pounds on a car?

Edited by jc2 on 24/10/2015 at 14:21

all / any - Engine oil - SteveLee

Due to extended service intervals modern oil is designed to suspend wear particules in the oil rather than allow them to settle forming sludge - similarly modern oil filters are actually quite porous or they would block after 15,000 miles. This means your oil, over time, becomes a fine grinding paste - the engine will still last 100,000+ miles however change the oil regularly (between services) and you will double engine life. It doesn't matter which oil as long as the specs are correct.

all / any - Engine oil - skidpan

Don't really agree with the previous post at all.

Modern oils are way better than oils of earlier years but so are the cars they are used in. Parts are made better out of better materials and as a result wear less especially when combined with the modern lubricants. Sludge does not contain only wear particles, it mostly results form the oil being overheated. Modern oils will handle much higher temps for much longer than oils of old therefore you do not see sludge.

Modern filters are also much better than filters of years ago and do not, as stated above allow metal particles to pass through and wear out your engine.

If you were able to turn the clock back and take a 100,000 mile old engine from the 60's or 70's and then strip and meaure all the the components and then do the same to a modern engine you would find that the modern engine exhibits very little wear.

How do I know, its because I have done it. When I raced we used Ford x-flow engines. The engines came out of Escorts and whilst they ran OK the sumps would be full of sludge, the bores would be worn (sometimes with broken rings) the cranks would show sufficient wear to need a regrind etc etc. The last engines I have bought from scrappies have been 2 litre Zetec's from Mondeo's with about 120,000 on the clock. Stripped and all they need is a new gasket and bolt set. No sludge in the sumps, honing marks still visible in the bores, cranks perfect, cams and followers still servicable (but they did show slight signs of wear).

No comparison.

all / any - Engine oil - DirtyDieselDogg

My father was adamant that keeping an eye on the quantity of oil in the sump was near as important as changing it, though back in his day, most engines when worked hard probably consumed an oil changes worth of oil between changes, therefore really only the filter required changing!

I however am a bit anal retentive re following the manufacturers guidance, but no more,

i.e. no Mobile 1 for a 30 year old "G" Wagen, just a reputable brand "to spec" oil.

I used to enjoy winding "Mobile 1 type" using nuts by stating, and with complete honesty that I ran the TDI in the Galaxy on tractor oil.

To 253,000 absolutly untroubled miles.

Perfectly true, being Case No1 engine oil, and who owned Case?, but Tennaco! and it met the relevant VW spec.

And from our local Ag dealer in a 20l drum, about 1/2 the price as the nearest Car type branded 5litres.

all / any - Engine oil - mss1tw

That's pretty cool. How long do the engines last under race conditions?

all / any - Engine oil - skidpan

That's pretty cool. How long do the engines last under race conditions?

Providing they were maintained well with an oil change every couple of races, sympathetically driven (i.e. hard but not over revved etc) with a season end strip and checkover they could last for many years.

Some would spend far more than that but it was not really necessary at club level. Races were about 10 laps (20 minutes max) and probably 10 in a season so even with practice and test sessions that would amount to well under 1000 miles a year.

Quality components are essential, there is plenty of rubbish out there and also plenty of rubbish machine shops. Find a good supplier and machine shop and keep them sweet.

Even the best engine from internationally known workshops costing more than some complete cars could be destroyed in a few laps by an idiot. One chap had 2 cars at every meeting and it was not unkown for him to destroy both engines or crash at least one. Never had a good finish but a mate of mine made £1000's keeping his cars on the track. He never learnt but kept trying.

Would not surprise me if my best 3 x-flow engines are not still out there. The last I built (and rebuilt after selling it to a mate) went to France to race. The first went to Japan in the early 90's, might still exist I guess. 2nd engine was particularly annoying, always went well but I wanted something with more cc's and power so I found the bits and built one of the best out there. Kept No 2 under the bench for several years but sold it to a mate after he kept pestering me. He gave it a good checkover, fitted one of his own heads and fitted it into a super lightweight chassis. First time out he finished ahead of me which was particularly annoying since he was in a smaller cc class and had less power, but power/weight (and skill) won the day.

Swapped to Mondeo Zetec's eventually for a challange. Wanted to make the car go as fast with a bog standard Ford engine (with Webers etc) as it had with a highly tuned race x-flow. Still got the first Zetec I built under the bench. Out of a burn out for £100 the only parts I changed were the rod bolts to enable more revs safely. Engine stood me at just a few hundred pounds yet made more power than a several thousand pound x-flow. Got some good results but decided to build another with cams, headwork, TB injection, race pistons etc. Went really well but ran the bearings when the oil filter O ring popped out. Sold the oily bits for a profit and fitted a brand new crate Focus Zetec engine. Don't race now, but 175 bhp in a 600kg car is faster than most cars on the road.

No 1 Zetec may resurface when I retire in a project, just got a house to rebuild at present.

all / any - Engine oil - SteveLee

www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/01/toyota_slud...l

www.oilsludge.com/

There a dailmer and Toyota sludge issue for you - plenty more examples out there - Saab for instance.

I used to build race engines as well - yes modern engines are much better engineered, wear at start-up is the main issue - and that is accelerated when you have aged oil suspending wear particules.

all / any - Engine oil - skidpan

www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2007/01/toyota_slud...l

www.oilsludge.com/

There a dailmer and Toyota sludge issue for you - plenty more examples out there - Saab for instance.

Irrelevant to us this side of the pond. Its for cars before 2002 and in the States they still tend to use old fashioned oils with short change intervals. Miss a change and sludge is still a risk today with those oils.

Use the correct modern oils and you won't have an issue.

The x-flows from scrappers I used to strip all had sumps full of sludge, they probably used some 10w40 or 20w50 mineral oil all their lives. The Zetecs have both been unbelieveably clean and probably used the correct 5w30 Semi Synthetic.

Its called progress.

all / any - Engine oil - john farrar
Regarding oil filters, has anyone any idea what micron rating they have and whether this is a nominal figure or an absolute number. Additionally has anyone any data on the size distribution of metallic particles found in used oil from normal engine use?

The reason that I ask was to gain some knowledge on how effective the average oil filter is; my guess is that they remove the larger ' bits' say above 5 micron?? but do little for much else. Have any papers been published?

Maybe it doesn't matter but Iam just curious.
all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer
Regarding oil filters, has anyone any idea what micron rating they have and whether this is a nominal figure or an absolute number.

I'm certainly no authority on it but, I'm pretty sure it differs depending on application or at least that was suggested to me when I approached Mann Hummels technical department some time ago.

Full flow filters will always have to be a compromise between filtration and flow rate.

I do have an oil filter in the garage and it says on the box that it filters to 15 microns.

When I had my Toyota the oil filter had two elements inside, one was a full flow element and the second one looked like a bypass filter.

Edited by Wackyracer on 27/10/2015 at 23:41

all / any - Engine oil - nortones2
Site called "Bob is the oil guy" has a lot of info about used oil analysis, and reams about filtration. How much reliance can be placed on it is another matter.


all / any - Engine oil - dadbif
I believe all oil filters have a bypass valve, so if the filter becomes blocked a flow of unfiltered oil gets to the engine, better than no oil at all.... But not recommended!
all / any - Engine oil - Andrew-T
I believe all oil filters have a bypass valve, so if the filter becomes blocked a flow of unfiltered oil gets to the engine, better than no oil at all.

That may well be the case now. But in the 90s (and later) one had to check that the new filter for a Pug 205 had a bypass, as some didn't.

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer
I believe all oil filters have a bypass valve, so if the filter becomes blocked a flow of unfiltered oil gets to the engine, better than no oil at all.

That may well be the case now. But in the 90s (and later) one had to check that the new filter for a Pug 205 had a bypass, as some didn't.

The filters (spin on type) for our Astra do not have a bypass valve in them, the bypass valve is fitted in the engine and no doubt better quality than ones inside some of the spin on filters I've opened up.

all / any - Engine oil - DirtyDieselDogg

And again "a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing"

i read an account of a maint guy who "wrecked" a Caterpillar fleet, by cleverely (he thought) purchasing non-Cat spec oil filters, because they filtered even better than the Cat spec filters.

So that ud be all right.

Cept the Cat spec filters were designed to permit sufficient oil flow.

The finer filter didnt, nor did it have a bypass.

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

And again "a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing"

i read an account of a maint guy who "wrecked" a Caterpillar fleet, by cleverely (he thought) purchasing non-Cat spec oil filters, because they filtered even better than the Cat spec filters.

So that ud be all right.

Cept the Cat spec filters were designed to permit sufficient oil flow.

The finer filter didnt, nor did it have a bypass.

It's not that hard unless your an idiot, all good filter manufacturers have catalogues to tell you which filter they produce to your engine manufacturers spec and if in doubt you can always contact their technical team. I tend to only use Purflux or Mann filters.

all / any - Engine oil - dadbif
Someone posting earlier mentioned bobistheoilguy, here is his explanation of bypass valves in oil filters....

www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=s...6
all / any - Engine oil - skidpan

My experience.

The 2.0 Zetec in my Caterham cannot use the standard Ford Focus/Mondeo filter with valve in it due to space considerations. For years I had been using the same filter (genuine Ford Escort Mk 2 OHV) which was short enough to fit but did not have a valve and I never had an issue.

Then at a trackday a major calamity happened, the O ring seal on the filter came adrift and 5 litres of Motuls finest was dumped on the track, fellow members were not happy and I had a knocking engine. I know the filter was secure the night before as it was part of my pre event checks.

When I stripped the engine I found the pressure relief valve in the oil pump was stuck in the closed position. The valve allows excess pressure to bleed oil strait back to the sump when the engine is at high revs preventing issues with oil seals etc. Since the filter fitted had no bypass valve there was no secondary way for pressure to be relieved so the oil found the easiest way out by dislodging the O ring.

You cannot legistlate aginst such things happening but I have since located a Mahle filter intended for the Ford KA and Fiesta OHV engines that fits perfectly and has a bypass valve. Fingers crossed for the future.

all / any - Engine oil - Wackyracer

When I stripped the engine I found the pressure relief valve in the oil pump was stuck in the closed position. The valve allows excess pressure to bleed oil strait back to the sump when the engine is at high revs preventing issues with oil seals etc. Since the filter fitted had no bypass valve there was no secondary way for pressure to be relieved so the oil found the easiest way out by dislodging the O ring.

Even if the filter did have a bypass valve it might still have happened. It would still be dependant on what the maximum flow rate of oil which can be pushed through the bearing clearances etc.

Dare I ask if your Caterham has an oil pressure gauge?

all / any - Engine oil - skidpan

Dare I ask if your Caterham has an oil pressure gauge?

It does but it needs a better man than me to watch the gauge whilst pushing hard on the track. A glance at the gauges whilst on the straits is as good as it gets.

Got a huge oil pressure warning light but its only good for low pressure, its set at 20 psi instead the OEM 5 psi to give plenty of warning.

For the record Zetecs have very high oil pressure after years of x-flows. A healthy x-flow just rebuilt would have a hot pressure of about 60 psi with revs over 4000. A Zetec manages 80 psi at about 2500 rpm. My gauge only gos to 100 psi and when cold any more than 3500 rpm and the needle hits the stop. That is with 5w30 oil.