VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote

Honest John Back Room » Motoring discussion
View Threaded
Thu 25 Apr 2013 21:35
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - JonestHon

Our old Passat (190k) is getting rrr. older and need few bit and bobs to get her through the MOT and she need a full service (every 20k miles we do this). We have few garages near us and due to the car needing back ASAP (Our only car) I can't shop around too far and have no space to do any work like changing filters etc'. I was given a quote today (South Gloucestershire area) by my regular garage but I can't tell if I am beeing overcharged or not, labor in both garages I checked is around £50-55/hour, can you please tell if this is resonable?

1.MOT = £40

2. 5 Litre Magnatec engine oil =£20

3. Service kit (oil, air fuel, pollen filters)=£46.71

3.CV boot x 2 + grease = 2x 74.95= £149.9

4.Rear brake pads and disk=£141

5. 2 x Uniroyal Rain Expert 195/65/15 Tyres =£97.9

6.Wheel alingment=£23.5

7. ABS sensor right hand=55.95

Tot: £574 + 20% vat = £689

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 25 Apr 2013 21:56
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - daveyjp
I can save you £8 as there is no VAT on an MOT!
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 25 Apr 2013 22:02
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - 72 dudes

A good way to check is to go on eurocarparts and plug in your reg number and look at the parts prices.

I'm no mechanic or even a DIYer, but the oil, service kit and tyres look good value.

The CV boots, rear discs and pads and ABS sensor look expensive however...

On the other hand, the "full service" without the extra items comes out around £240 which isn't far out.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 00:01
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - 659FBE

Putting "Magnatec" oil into a VAG PD diesel engine which is serviced at about 20k mile intervals will cause camshaft and follower failure. The correct oil for this duty is a fully synthetic lubricant to VAG specification 507.00.

Allowing these vehicles to be worked on by ill-informed or non motivated parties spells disaster and will grossly inflate overall running costs.

Find a good Independent who specialises in these vehicles.

659.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 00:12
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - daveyjp
I read that the car has done almost 200,000 miles. Plenty of time for camshaft failures using cheap oil and and extended intervals.

Makes you wonder if VAG have an angle to extract cash during service time, like they do over the cambelt change interval.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 00:18
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - JonestHon

My error it's not Magnatec but 5 litre of Castrol Edge 5w-30 fully synth (I was looking at the bouchure attached and not the actual quote).

The prices all include labour, why the hell replacing the CV boots cost so much? I must admit tho that while driving this car over 100k ourself it never needed CV boots or new disks at the back, which is good. When we got her six years ago she was on long intervals but we always change oil every 10k and get her fully serviced every 20k. Intresting you mention the cam belt, my book show that we changed it at 120k so she is due for another on very soon, my garage is a VW specialist and they want £299 for the job and parts (kit and water pump), is this sound reasonable?

Edited by ModelT on 26/04/2013 at 00:24

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 08:03
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - Simon
If the prices include the labour for each bit then I don't think that it is bad at all. Some jobs are more labour intensive than others - ie the CV boots. You are having a lot of work done in one go, that's why it is a big bill.

Edited by Simon on 26/04/2013 at 08:04

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 10:29
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - oldtoffee

The cambelt and water pump change sounds about right. Last year I paid £320 in the South East at a good VAG independent and they fitted an Audi water pump which they reckoned is a bit better than the VW unit. All your other quotes look either good (the servicing kits and oil) or reasonable for the brakes and CVs.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 10:31
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - JonestHon

Thank you Simon,

I think I will get ahead and book myself in, I think you are right as it is multiple consumable change so I should expect a large bill.

The car came with full service history from a small engineering firm and when I look at this carefully I see that she is still on the original Clutch and exhaust while the back pads and disk were nver changed either (but were inspected every service).

It is either a testimony to how durable the components on these cars are or the fact that she was serviced regulary all these years.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 22:52
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - corax

I must admit tho that while driving this car over 100k ourself it never needed CV boots or new disks at the back, which is good.

There aren't any CV boots at the back, it's front wheel drive.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sun 28 Apr 2013 15:47
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - Roly93

Putting "Magnatec" oil into a VAG PD diesel engine which is serviced at about 20k mile intervals will cause camshaft and follower failure. The correct oil for this duty is a fully synthetic lubricant to VAG specification 507.00.

Allowing these vehicles to be worked on by ill-informed or non motivated parties spells disaster and will grossly inflate overall running costs.

Find a good Independent who specialises in these vehicles..

Good advice, these cars are durable as long as you always use 506 or 507 spec oil. These engines will take either but later DPF equiped cars needed the 507 spec.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Fri 26 Apr 2013 16:03
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - A3 A4

Agree with 72 dudes, Eurocarparts also regularly offer 25% discount codes, the filter kit looks a little costly.

Try also GSF they supply Mann filters, which stranglely are cheaper if buy via their Ebay shop.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sun 28 Apr 2013 13:40
VW Passat TD 2003 PD 130 Estate - Opinion about a quote - Simon

Agree with 72 dudes, Eurocarparts also regularly offer 25% discount codes, the filter kit looks a little costly.

Yes but if the price also includes the labour associated with fitting each part, then the filter kit is not expensive at all.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.

The Good Garage Guide