BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4

Honest John Back Room » Motoring discussion
View Threaded
Sat 28 Oct 2023 11:06
BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4 - Icru96
Hi
Super confused with the above two models.
Not sure which one would be the best for me. For my budget I might get a 70k mile example of both.
I would Lloyd to know your opinion on both. Please do let me know how reliable these cars are and how much it would cost for servicing.

Thank you
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 28 Oct 2023 11:19
BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4 - Adampr

All things being equal, I would expect the Leon to be more reliable and cheaper to maintain.

Is there a particular reason you're looking at a diesel and a petrol?

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 28 Oct 2023 11:29
BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4 - Icru96
No particular reason,

I was mainly looking for a good drivers car under 8k budget.
If you guys have any other good recommendations, I would love to hear.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 28 Oct 2023 11:23
BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4 - badbusdriver

Not sure either are a good option.

The BMW definitely isn't a great car, not particularly reliable, cramped in the rear, poorly packaged and more likely to have been thrashed.

Whether or not a Leon is a good buy depends on whether one of that age has a chain or belt drive. If it has a belt, it is much better car than the 1 Series, but if it has a chain, I wouldn't have it either.

Edited by badbusdriver on 28/10/2023 at 11:24

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 28 Oct 2023 17:08
BMW 1 Series - BMW 116ED 2016 vs seat Leon 2014 1.4 - skidpan

This is my past experience of a BMW 1 series and a Seat Leon 1.4.

Mine was a 118D ES Edition. Had it for almost 6 years and other than servicing and consumables the only additional expense was battery (replaced under warranty) and a pair of front springs. Over those 6 years it averaged about 48 mpg (calculated not form the lying dash display). I accept they don't have great rear space but that was not an issue for us which was why we bought it. Compared to the other cars we looked at (Golf, Civic, Auris, Ceed etc) it was head and shoulders better and not a lot more money.

When we came to replace it another 1 series was the front runner (a 118i petrol since my mileage had dropped) but just before this the new Leon had been released and we went for a look and drive. It was a 1.4 TSi 140 PS in SE trim. Within a few hundred metres we knew it was the car we were buying. It was better than the 1 series in pretty much every respect, in the others it was a match. Over the 3 1/2 years we had it we had no issues at all, just servicing, not even a set of tyres. It averaged a genuine 45 mpg which when you take into account the extra cost of diesel pretty much made the fuel costs the same. Only sold it because a change in our need made the car too small. Bought a Skoda Superb which was mechanically identical, just bigger.

Both are great cars providing you get a good one (just like any car).

Are you feeling lucky considering you are proposing buying a 8 to 10 year old car?

Reply | Report as offensive | Link