Which comfortable automatic car to replace my BMW Z4?

I have a 2009 manual BMW Z4 2.5 which I have owned for about 10 months. It looks great but is not overly comfortable on long runs, the gear changes don't appear to be smooth, it is very impractical and I don't like the auto handbrake coupled with a manual. So I have decided to look for something else. I like the Audi A5 Quattro 3.0TDI and I have found a couple of similar age. I like the thought of better ability to cope with snow (assuming I put winter tyres on), that it is full of exciting technology and toys with the satnav, plus and driver info and has comfort and space with an auto box. Most have done 50,000 miles for the money I can spend. However, what else should I look at that offers such a package coupled with a sense of style? The A5 seems big, so something slightly smaller would be better.

Asked on 25 May 2013 by PRM, via email

Answered by Honest John
Not clear if your car is a Z4 23i with electric folding hardtop or the previous Z4 2.5i soft top. BMW has just revised the Z4 yet again. That said, the A5 coupe is a nice car. Very good looking: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/audi/audi-a5-and-s.../

Smaller, the obvious choice is an S3: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/audi/audi-s3-2007-.../ Less looks. Strong performance.
Similar questions
I'm in the process of choosing my new car. I definitely want a four-wheel drive because I like to drive to the mountains in wintertime. My primary concern is great handling of the car for fast cornering....
Can you recommend a new car with as few gadgets as possible but space for dogs and lots of fishing gear. Doesn't need to be 4wd but ground clearance required, and switching off seat belt beeping required...
I have seen advertised in a newspaper, a device you plug into a cars 12v point (ciggy Lighter) when charged you remove the device and if you have a flat battery in future simply re-insert the device into...
Related models
Spacious boot. Solid build quality. Good to drive on the motorway. Good handling with quattro all-wheel drive.
Stylish and refined roadster coupe with folding hard top. Strong performance from six-cylinder engines. Much improved steering feel came as part of 2013 revamp.
Powered by smooth 2.0 TFSI engine with 300PS. Quattro four-wheel drive means superb traction. Lighter weight helps economy with an official 40mpg.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer