Which car to replace our Volkswagen Passat and Vauxhall Astra?

The passage of time has brought the wife (age 75) and me (age 78) to a point where the ease at which we can enter and leave the car is becoming paramount. I currently run a 1997 Passat 110 TDI now at 177,000 miles. My wife has a 2005 1.4 Astra. The plan is to pass to Passat onto a family member and either trade or sell the Astra for somewhere around £2000 to £2,500, add £5000 to £8000 and see what I can get. For some time now our annual mileage has dropped to 5000-7000 miles with me doing most of the driving. I have been doing some research and my interest centres around either a Mitsubishi ASX or a Mercedes B-Class in the 3-5 year bracket, petrol, up to 2.0-litre.

Asked on 23 March 2013 by GB, Leeds

Answered by Honest John
Not bad choices, and Mitsubishi reliability is impressive. I'd also look at a Ford C-Max, preferably a 1.8i or 2.0i petrol and one with a proper lever-operated parking brake. It's very roomy in the front seats, very easy to get in and out of and generally very pleasant to drive.
Similar questions
My present car is a 1997 Honda Civic 1.6 petrol auto, owned from new. I need better access with a higher seat and would like a 5-door auto petrol hatchback of a similar size, but which? A Mercedes dealer...
We have a Hyundai i10 Classic. We are thinking of upgrading to a new Honda Jazz 1.2 SE manual for more comfort and the higher seats, as I have had back surgery. What are the pros and cons of this Jazz...
My motoring habits now consist of a few day trips and a six-week drive in the summer to Italy. When we go to Italy we take the long way round and cover approx 4000 miles. We have no kids. Our cars at present...
Related models
Raised driving position, lots of interior room, decent diesel engines, good ride quality on smaller wheels.
Well-equipped as standard. Impressive Real MPG scores. Plenty of room for five plus luggage.
Neat styling. More practical than a Ford Focus. Fine blend of ride comfort, handling and driver enjoyment. High-quality interior.