Does coasting downhill use more fuel than remaining in gear?

Some tell me that coasting downhill in neutral uses more fuel than remaining in gear. However, the MPG computer in my 1992 Corrado G60 says otherwise. Do the same rules apply to both new and older cars?

Asked on 16 June 2012 by BC, Woodbridge

Answered by Honest John
In modern cars the fuel supply is shut off entirely on lift-off, but when coasting the engine needs fuel to idle. Not a lot of difference, but enough to state that coasting uses more fuel than simply lifting off in gear. I can't tell you if the fuel shuts off in a supercharged Corrado but it's amazing that the fuel computer still works at all on a 20-year-old car.
Similar questions
More than once in your column I've seen complaints by readers that cruise control is a fuel waster. I was always under the impression that cruise control allows the engine management system to select the...
I sold my Golf once it was repaired and replaced it with Ford Focus 125 Ecoboost, which is really nice to drive. I see the real world MPG for this car does look a little disappointing but I'm soon going...
Last year I bought a brand new 2012 Ford C-Max Zetec, and I have got to say the mpg I am getting is nowhere near as good as the manufacturer stated. I understand I will not get 68.9mpg. However, I have...