Why don't car manufacturers use a different method for keyless entry fobs to avoid radio interference?

With regard to your reply to the problem with the keyless entry system on the Toyota RAV4. This problem is because the car manufactures install these keyless systems which have key fobs that have virtually no RF screening whatsoever. They can be swamped by other local radio transmissions across a very wide frequency range.

I am a licensed amateur radio operator and operate VHF/UHF radio equipment from my car that is very narrow band that has to comply with stringent regulations regarding bandwidth. Most keyless entry systems on vehicles operate around 433mHz and they are so poor that they can blocked with a nearby radio transmission, anywhere from 430 to 440mHz. I used to wait in my car whilst my wife is in the supermarket, and I would talk to other local radio amateurs on my UHF transmitter. Whilst I was transmitting the majority of people within a 100-metre radius could not lock or unlock their cars using the key fob.

All radio transmitting equipment used in the UK and Europe is regulated and is very stable in its transmission. Perhaps car manufacturers ought to get their act together and provide some decent keyless systems, preferably infrared. Taxi radio installations do not operate on 433mHz.

Asked on 12 May 2011 by RP, Whitstable

Answered by Honest John
Yes, other radio hams have made the same point. But for every radio ham there must be 10,000 car owners facing a problem with their remote keys. So I wouldn't shout too loudly because the same legislators who created this mistake may decide to rectify it by banning amateur radio transmissions entirely.
Similar questions
I have a Renault espace MK4, the card key opens the doors but won't start the car. I've put a new battery in the key card but it has made no difference.
Regarding wireless doorbells and car remotes, we have just such a doorbell, with a choice of treble or bass chimes. Ours is set to treble, but from time to time the bass would blast out when no one was...
I've just read the item titled "Wave machine", and can provide you with a bit of clarification on the matter. The keyless entry and ignition system in the Toyota RAV4 will probably use a small radio frequency...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer