Is your local garage worth shouting about? We want to hear about it. | No thanks
Ask Honest John  
Ask a Question

What's your question? Search here

Vectra gearbox failure at 37,700 miles
I bought a Vectra 1.9 CDTi Estate in April 2009. Recently, while on holiday in Cornwall, the gearbox lost 5th & 6th gears and there is a whining noise in 1st gear.

On return from holiday I rang the Vauxhall Pentagon dealership in Derby, firstly to ask whether it maybe covered by any warranty, (the car had its first service by Vauxhall before I owned it and its second service was carried out by a local garage (Hawkins & Shepherd, Liversage st, Derby,) who use genuine parts. Its third service was due in April but it is yet to have this.

The service department Manger said they would not cover this at all.

I also asked if they could give me an idea of repair costs. They offered to test drive it but then also suggested they may need to strip it down to see what the problem could be and wanted to charge me £78 an hour.

I have therefore taken the car to my garage (Hawkins & Shepherd) they have test drove it and suggest it needs a new gear box (I believe the model of gear box is M32) or possibly the gearbox may be repairable depending on the amount of damage caused inside the box.

The worst case would be a gearbox exchange & possibly a new clutch again depending on any damage. The cost if all of this is necessary will be around £1600.

I have 3 questions,
1 - is this a fair price?
2- in your opinion should a gearbox be able to do more than 37700 miles without going faulty, and if so is this M32 gearbox fit for purpose?
3- Should Vauxhall contribute towards its repair?
4- How should I go about persuading Vauxhall to contribute?

The car is booked in for next Tuesday 9th August, so any help would be very welcome.

Asked on 4 August 2011 by Carl65

Answered by Honest John
Fair price for the box. Haven't heard of this failure before on the 1.9 Vectra diesel. Plenty of engine failures, though. Plead for some goodwill, but you wont get any if you have a local garage repair it.
Similar questions
Honda are refusing to help me with my Jazz Gearbox problem on a 54 plate at 80,000, a known issue on Jazzes. I was wondering if you can offer any advice...
I note that one of your correspondents recently described his/her Honda Jazz as “a heap of unreliable junk”. Can I add my name to the list of dissatisfied...
I have a deadly serious problem with the EPS on my 2003/53 Vauxhall Meriva. The power steering cuts out as I'm driving along. This has happened many times....
Related links
Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.
Related models
Far better than previous Vectra. Now with decent handling and an excellent ride. Plenty of safety kit. Roomy in the front. Big boot. Good looks.

Cars For Sale




Reader Offers and Prizes

Buying Advice

Honest John's Newsletter

Latest News & Road Tests

Connect with Honest John

Facebook YouTube