Are all-season tyres worth the extra cost?

My SEAT Ateca tyres (215/55/R17 94V) are down to 4mm and will be replaced in the next couple of months. Are all-season tyres worth investing in considering the extra expense? If they are, which ones do you recommend? Which ordinary tyres would you recommend if I choose not to purchase all-weather tyres? Comfort, durability, braking effectiveness and road noise are obviously required for any tyres I will purchase. Are there any deals out there for the purchase of four tyres? Many thanks.

Asked on 14 April 2021 by Neil Stevens

Answered by Georgia Petrie
Whether you need/want all-season tyres will really depend on how capable you find your current tyres. All-season tyres are more expensive, so depends on whether you'd be getting the best value from them. For example, if you live on a hill or down a steep driveway, regularly see snow and/or ice where you live, or simply find summer tyres don't give you the grip you want in winter months etc - then I'd advise all-season tyres. If you see regular bad weather that affects your driving, I'd probably suggest swapping between summer and winter instead — i.e. northern parts of England and Scotland could require winter tyres more so than all-season as the weather can get more severe than, say, in the Midlands.

If you want all-season tyres then I'd recommend Michelin CrossClimate+ or Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2. As for 'standard' summer tyres, I'd probably go with the Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance 2 as they're quiet (A for wet grip, B for fuel economy, fairly quiet) and refined. Another choice would be Michelin Primacy 4 (A for wet grip, fairly quiet but only a C for fuel economy). Bridgestone Turanza are rated A for fuel economy and wet grip, however, they're rated at 71dB for noise, which can be considerably louder than tyres under 70dB.

I'd check Kwik Fit and Black Circles for deals, Black Circles certainly has some for the ones I've mentioned. ASDA tyres might also be worth a look for offers and discounts. It's best to shop around online as the deals change regularly but there are usually offers to be had if you're buying a full set.
Similar questions
Saab 9-3 2-door soft top vector 175 bhp 37000 miles fsh 1 lady owner since 2007, full leather, fully equipped. Garage asking £6995. The price looks a bit high, but they assure me its absolutely perfect....
Earlier today, with my car temperature gauge reading 30 degrees Celsius I saw two young boys sitting in the back seat of a Ford Ka in a supermarket car park. Their only ventilation was the two rear quarter...
I bought an Audi TTS roadster 2 years ago to replace my wife's MR2 and as a 'fun' car for me. Unfortunately my wife has not taken to the Audi. I think its time to consider an alternative. I reckon its...
Related models
Probably the best handling car in its class. Lots of room for those in the back along with a large boot. Good value for money. Range of economical and swift engines.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer