Britain’s cheapest car to run revealed – and the most expensive...

The Dacia Sandero has been named the most affordable car to own and run in the UK, according to a  comprehensive new study.

Car insurance comparison firm Quotezone selected 50 of the UK's most popular cars, with the aim to discover how much someone running one would spend each year. 

The research factored in costs including finance, fuel or vehicle efficiency in the case of electric cars, insurance, tax and maintenance.

The research highlighted a £16,476 running cost gap between the most affordable and most expensive models on the market. 

At the very bottom of that cost scale sat the petrol-powered Dacia Sandero with a total annual running cost of just £7715 – less than a third of the £24,191 required by the UK’s most expensive model, the electric BMW i4.

Dacia leads the way

The value-champion £14,765 Dacia Sandero was the UK's cheapest car to buy and run. Quotezone calculated that it would cost £7715 to cover the Sandero's costs for a year, helped by the fact that its finance bill of £4337 and insurance at £626 were the cheapest of any car in the data set.

The Renault 5 ranked second, costing an estimated £7985 a year, while the MG 3 came third, as the second most affordable petrol car, costing £8630 a year. 

And the most expensive...

Quotezone estimates that running a new BMW i4 costs an average of £24,191. Despite being the 11th cheapest car to fuel from the 50 cars listed, finance charges for the i4 were a hefty £21,011, while an annual insurance policy added £1430 to the bill.

A major driver of the expensive finance is the first-year depreciation suffered by the BMW. Costing £71,525 new, the i4 selected by Quotezone would lose £17,881, or 25% of its value, in the first year.

Second to the BMW is the Land Rover Defender with yearly running costs of £22,820. The heavy Defender costs an estimated £3248 in fuel, the highest of any of the 50 cars selected, while almost £17,000 in finance costs – pushed up by £14,314 in first-year depreciation – added to the overall bill.

Rounding out the top three is the Audi Q6 e-tron at £22,639 per year – just £180 less than the Defender and costing over £18,000 to finance. The Audi was second to the BMW in terms of depreciation, also losing 25% of its value, dropping £15,329 in the first year compared to £61,315 when new.

How about the average costs?

Using data for its 50 cars, Quotezone states that the average cost of a new car from its list was £33,395, and the average it costs to run a car in the UK is a not-unsubstantial £13,364.

As far as a breakdown of figures goes, finance is by far the biggest factor, costing an average of £9810, while fuel (£2108), insurance (£990), taxes (£253) and maintenance (£203) make up the rest.

Top 20 cheapest cars to run in the UK

Rank

Make

Model

Engine type

Annual Fuel cost

Annual Maintenance

Annual Insurance

Annual Road Taxes*

Annual Running Cost

1

Dacia

Sandero

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£626

£200

£7,715

2

Renault

5

Electric

£655

£170

£646

£200

£7,985

3

MG

3

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£738

£200

£8,630

4

Vauxhall

Corsa

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£639

£200

£9,192

5

Omoda

5

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£822

£200

£9,461

6

Peugeot

208

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£838

£200

£9,615

7

MG

ZS

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£965

£200

£9,737

8

Volkswagen

Polo

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£688

£200

£9,919

9

Renault

Captur

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£715

£200

£10,075

10

Nissan

Juke

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£744

£200

£10,625

*based on second year prices

Top 20 most expensive cars to run in the UK

Rank

Make

Model

Engine type

Annual Fuel cost

Annual Maintenance

Annual Insurance

Annual Road Taxes*

Annual Running Cost

1

BMW

i4

Electric

£900

£210

£1,430

£640

£24,191

2

Land Rover

Defender

Petrol or diesel

£3,248

£395

£1,717

£640

£22,820

3

Audi

Q6 e-tron

Electric

£1,125

£395

£2,468

£640

£22,639

4

BMW

X1

Petrol

£2,382

£170

£1,047

£640

£19,680

5

BYD

Seal U

Hybrid

£2,680

£210

£1,442

£200

£17,965

6

Toyota

RAV4

Hybrid

£2,680

£210

£921

£640

£17,331

7

BMW

3 Series

petrol

£2,680

£210

£1,372

£640

£17,224

8

Audi

Q4 e-tron

Electric

£947

£210

£1,282

£200

£16,550

9

Skoda

Kodiaq

Petrol or diesel

£3,248

£395

£822

£200

£16,394

10

Tesla

Model Y

Electric

£900

£210

£1,808

£200

£15,452

Ask HJ

What is a good choice of car for a pensioner?

I have the opportunity of purchasing two different cars at part exchange prices from family members. I am happy with my current 2019 SEAT Arona with 50k but am tempted by a 2017 Ford Kuga with only 32k and a Toyota C-HR with 64k. All in splendid condition and with long MoT. I drive 8-10,000 miles a year mostly leisure but also commuting to my part time job. As I am 76 I really am aiming for this to be maybe my final car and I wish to keep costs under control. As I am having difficulty in deciding I was looking for a professional unbiased opinion on what choice would make most sense.
If running costs are a key consideration then we would expect the hybrid Toyota to be cheaper than the Ford Kuga, although this does depend on which engines are fitted. However, we would give serious consideration to keeping your current vehicle - you say you are happy with it, it is still relatively new and younger than the Ford despite the higher mileage, while the Toyota's mileage is higher still. If you don't need any more space than the Arona offers you then sticking with your existing car is usually cheaper than selling it and buying something else, even if you are getting them at a good price.
Answered by David Ross
More Questions