Worn tyres ‘as dangerous as mobile phone use’, study reveals

Driving with tyres at the UK legal tread limit of 1.6mm can be more dangerous than using a mobile phone at the wheel. 

That's according to a new academic study conducted by Cardiff University and commissioned by Halfords,

The research found that at motorway speeds, a car with worn-but-legal tyres takes significantly longer to stop than a vehicle driven by someone distracted by a phone.

The study compared the reaction times of distracted drivers against the physical performance of tyres with 1.6mm of tread — the minimum depth required to pass an MoT.

At 70mph, using a mobile phone adds an average of 15.55 metres to a car's stopping distance due to slower driver reaction times. However, tyres worn to the legal limit add a staggering 27 metres (approximately six car lengths) compared to a car with tyres in good condition.

While a car with healthy tyres will stop in 96 metres from 70mph, a car with 1.6mm tread depth requires 123 metres to come to a halt.

The findings have sparked a debate over whether the UK’s current 1.6mm limit is safe. Experts from TyreSafe and Halfords suggest that the legal minimum should not be mistaken for a safety benchmark.

"Tyre performance begins to become impaired long before they reach the legal limit. From a stopping distance perspective, the impact of worn tyres is generally worse than phone usage," says Professor Peter Wells, Director of the Centre for Automotive Industry Research at Cardiff University.

Government data supports the concern, showing that deaths or serious injuries resulting from dangerous tyres rose from 147 in 2022 to 172 in 2024.

Drivers unaware of the risks

Despite the physical dangers, public perception remains skewed. The study revealed that only 7% of drivers believe worn tyres are more dangerous than phone use. Furthermore:

  • 28% of motorists do not know the legal limit is 1.6mm.
  • 28% are not confident they could identify when their tyres need replacing.
  • 31% of drivers believe the current legal limit should be raised.

Both Professor Wells and Halfords are now urging motorists to consider replacing their tyres once they reach 3mm of tread, rather than waiting for the legal 1.6mm limit.

"We encourage all motorists to treat tyre maintenance with the same seriousness as they do mobile phone use," says Stuart Lovatt, Chair of TyreSafe.

To help drivers stay safe, Halfords is offering a free ten-point car safety check (worth £15) and free tyre checks at any Halfords or National Tyres garage for those who sign up for their free Motoring Club.

Ask HJ

Is a tyre with sidewall damage safe?

Recently I hit a kerb with my front offside tyre on a badly lit road where the pavement had been built out on a corner and when I inspected it the following day there was a 50mm strip of rubber partially sheared away from the tyre wall just below the tread area. When I took it to my local tyre centre they said it was okay to drive on if there was no air leakage. I thought this was dubious advice as I didn’t want to have a blowout if the tyre became unsafe and understand that tyre walls are not that thick (mine are 215 60 R17 for a Suzuki Vitara). I asked for the tyre to be changed and when I asked what they would do with the old one (which wasn’t very worn) they said they would throw it away as it could not be sold again. Was I correct to change it immediately and would that kind of damage have resulted in an MoT fail?
Any damage to a tyre should be taken seriously and if you are unsure of the severity of the damage we would recommend having a trusted garage or tyre fitter examine the damage. The MoT inspection manual states that 'A tyre with a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords' is considered a major fault, so it may be that this damage was not sufficient to fail. However, significant damage to the sidewall can weaken the structure with the potential risk of deflation, failure or even a blowout, so we would always err on the side of caution.
Answered by David Ross
More Questions