Recommend a Sat Nav? - Redhound

My SatNav got nicked the other week before I had even used it, so I would be interested in any recommendations before I replace it; I plan to use it as back up for some long distance, house-hunting trips and my only criteria are that it is easy to use, accurate and has speed camera warnings built in at purchase, as my broadband is too slow to download anything (and I am a technophobe!) Would rather not spend too much and not bothered about live features- I dont think. Thanks

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Ethan Edwards

Days of the stand alone sat nav (Personal Navigation Device PND) are definitely numbered. Free Google maps on Android, Navfree application on iphone's etc.

That said your requirements as stated seem very modest and practically any PND should do the job. Most seem to like TomTom but I had a preference for Garmin profucts. These days I have a built in solution and the free Android Google thing as a 'back up'.

Cheers,

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Redhound

Oh OK I am obviously behind the times, thanks :)

Recommend a Sat Nav? - S40 Man

I had a Nokia 5230 ~£30 these days. It has Nokia maps built in, with speed camera warnings.

+ves a) reasonably cheap b) can live in your pocket so hard to nick

Works OK but screen too small for sat nav, I do it all by listening which worked OK

I now have HTC with google maps which is also OK but no speed camera warnings.

One on flea bay here as an example

www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Nokia-5230-Black-vodafone-Smart...1

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Redhound

That's an interesting idea thanks for that, I will have a ponder! Cheers.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Smileyman

If you need camera warnings then it might be better to buy a specialist speed management toy and let it help you stick to the speed limit, or warn you of cameras where you consider the limit has been set too low.(Yes, there are such places).

Just don't take it to France, they are illegal and the penalties are severe (probably not just frog march to nearest cash machine to empty your bank account).

If using mobile phone solution for sat-nav there is the added consideration of areas where the 3g / 2g connection fails or is very expensive if overseas.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - focussed

It really comes down to TomTom versus Garmin. I've got both. The TT software and usage is user friendly and effective-but their hardware is tacky and unreliable. The Garmin on the other hand is bomb-proof, but the software is obtuse, not user friendly and frustrating to use.

Somebody needs to invent the Tommin or the Gartom.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - xtrailman

I prefer the nissan built in sat nav. Plus it has a 7" screen.

I also have nokias maps, not impressed.

And a 1390T garmin, the garmin has speed cameras and post codes, the 2009 nissan satnav doesn't, but its guidance is far superior to the garmin and nokia.

And the garmin camera data base is never upto date.

I have only limited experience with a mazda cx5 with built in tom tom, and found the TT was very poor, small 5.5" screen, poor resolution, lost satellite lock, and gave slow and confusing guidance instructions.

Edited by xtrailman on 08/11/2012 at 22:09

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Collos25

The problem with Garmin is that they are slow and their mapping is woefully lacking in upto date information.Better of with a cheap chinese model of flebay.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - FP

I bought a TomTom XXL with European maps in the summer - it was on special offer at the time. It has a nice big screen, but is slim enough to fit into a coat pocket or man-bag.

It has worked faultlessly in the UK and in France/Monaco - I'm very happy with it. Boots up quickly, has a clear screen and spoken instructions.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Auristocrat

'I bought a TomTom XXL with European maps in the summer - it was on special offer at the time. It has a nice big screen.'

I have had a Tom Tom XXL Classic with European mapping for about 15 months. The screen is approx 5 inches in size and has lane guidance as well. Tom Tom have an up to date mapping guarantee - guarantees the most up-to-date mapping at the time of purchase. Just had two offers come through from Tom Tom - security cameras subscription for £6.65 for the year and half price mapping update for the year (£32) - both of which I've had. In use, we found it to be better than our previous Garmin Nuvi 2200.

Edited by Auristocrat on 09/11/2012 at 11:04

Recommend a Sat Nav? - bear807
After using a mobile app named Waze, I never go back to using traditional navigator. Having own a Tom Tom for past 3 years, it has been quite useless, one occasion I put in Chester zoo postcode, and the tom Tom brought me to a location and ask me to walk for a mile, another occasion I was driving on road and is showing me I'm cruising in the river. Is ridiculous, now is still in my car I would only use it if I cannot get reception on my phone.

Talking about waze is an amazing app, is like a social network gps. The traffic update is fairly good, because it is done by user reporting and satellite data. There were few times with this app I avoided hidden camera van. There is an disadvantage which you can't put in house no. Other then that it is very good!
Recommend a Sat Nav? - thunderbird

Got an £85 Garmin a couple of years ago. Never let me down yet. Works with the full post code or if you are going to a place in the sticks works of OS coords.

Very pleased.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - pinkpanther_75

I've used most of the previously mentiomed devices (Tomtom, Garmin, Navman, Nokia maps, Google maps) and have found Navfree very easy to use on an Android phone.

It is free and the maps are stored on the phone, so no issues with 2G/3G coverage and/or data charges,

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Redhound

Hmmm. Some diverse opinions here! I assume my basic Blackberry wouldn't be much good for this sort of thing? So, I probably do need a standard SatNav unit. I will probably just see what the best deal is going on Amazon for a basic unit as they all seem to have their faults. It is just for back up. Good point about them being illegal in France. Thanks for the thoughts.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - FP

Satnavs are NOT illegal in France. A previous post pointed out that dedicated speed camera warning devices ARE.

However, in France satnavs must not warn of precise speed camera locations, unlike in the UK. Satnavs may warn of "zones de danger", which will be several hundres of metres in length and may well include a speed camera.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - NARU

I use an adroid phone with google maps.

It means I can search for somewhere on my home PC, and then just 'star' the location - and it pops up automatically on the android as a destination. Absolutely brilliant.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Bobbin Threadbare

I use an adroid phone with google maps.

It means I can search for somewhere on my home PC, and then just 'star' the location - and it pops up automatically on the android as a destination. Absolutely brilliant.

Me too. I also still use paper maps, and look at the road signs. I'm not being facetious; I just wouldn't get my money's worth from a couple of hundred quid's worth of satnav unit.

Also my phone has an app called Carr Matey! which lets me pinpoint my car's location with GPS, record it, and then find it again by following a compass-type interface. This is very handy for in giant car parks or at festivals.

Recommend a Sat Nav? - Redhound

Ah OK thanks for clarifying the French legality issue. Sounds like I need to upgrade my mobile then. I am OK at map reading, but have you tried some of those maze-like, rural lanes in places like Devon with high hedges, its easy to lose track especially when driving alone and tricky having to keep stopping to look at the map. Sat Navs have their place occasionally I think.