Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - nantgaredig
Do you have an A1?

What do you think?

Looking at the 1.6 dti Sport.



Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - sandy56

its expensive for what it is- I would just go for the Golf.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Avant

Or the Polo which is the equivalent size.

I haven't tried an A1 but most road tests prefer the petrol 1.4 TSI. It depends on your annual mileage: I'd choose a petrol unless (for a small car like this) I did 20,000 + miles a year. The savings with small diesels aren't as great as with bigger cars.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - daveyjp
No room for a spare on diesels as the battery is in the boot. That's enough to put me off. Petrol has a skinny spare.
Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Roly93

I dont have one but have had both the 1.4 and 1.2 as loan cars.

Putting aside that fact that these cars are aimed at the young trendy semi-professional, and as such are not aimed at myself, ie 50 old school and married with family, they are quite nice little motors. Also putting aside the fact that they arent cheap, they are a quality little car with some nice features, taking over in stylishness from the now boring and estate-agent'ised BMW mini.

I was thoroughly impressed with the 1.4 engined variant, it was one of the strongest engines I have seen in years, and at 80 on the motorway it had diesel-like RPM with diesel-like grunt.

I'm sure my daughter would like one and if I stumble into some cash I may oblige !

So in summary IMHO a very nice car in the sector that it belongs to.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - grimep

Its the motoring equivalent of a designer handbag. Almost as silly as an Evoke.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Roly93

Its the motoring equivalent of a designer handbag. Almost as silly as an Evoke.

I think thats slightly harsh, if youve got the money and want a small car that is very well made and refined you look at the BMW mini or A1.

A designer handbag is something that costs 10+ x the price of a perfectly normal handbag just for a label.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - nantgaredig

I had a Mini some years back, great fun car but not practical with kids and a long journey was hard. Review talks about a big car feel, that's what I'm interesed in. Small car money and practicallity but a big car feel! Can't afford the big car anymore!!

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - nantgaredig

Thanks for the insight. Professor of Design and Enginnering I bet !

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Sulphur Man

A smart-looking, well made car, but one afflicted with the same issue as the last small Audi, the A2, namely blind spots. The thickness and rake of the A-pillar obscures a chunk of visibility, made more significant in a small, relatively narrow car. A number of motoring magazine reviewers have criticised both the fore and over-the-shoulder visibility of the car. One even questioned whether Audi had "heard of high strength steel yet?".

I went to our local dealership to have a look at one. A few minutes sitting in the drivers seat of the showroom one convinced me that the car's A-pillars are of sufficient girth to be obstructive in certain driving situations. Judging the over-the-shoulder visibility was not so valid in a showroom. But it's worth noting that Audi offers an optional 'blind spot' mirror inidcator system, which must be a first in such a small car. Perhaps they're subtly admitting that the car's design needs this assistance?

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Ethan Edwards

At least if your sitting inside it, you don't have to see the ugly exterior. Thats gotta be a huge selling point.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - gordonbennet

I'm with a couple of the others, it may well be a good little car if overpriced as are most VW/Audi badged offerings, but it takes ugly to a whole new level.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Pat L

Nice to see the old prejudices are alive and well! I've never driven one, let alone owned one, so I won't offer any opinion other than to say it's not ugly:)

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - gordonbennet

Nice to see the old prejudices are alive and well! I've never driven one, let alone owned one, so I won't offer any opinion other than to say it's not ugly:)

Thats the beauty about living in a society where for a while at least we have the choice, we don't have to buy something repulsive because the state requires it..;)

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Pat L

I assume the op has actually seen an A1 and therefore doesn't think it's ugly or repulsive. What he wants is real world experience of the car.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - dieseldogg

Strangly enough our completely non car interested son has decided that he liked the Audi A1, as opposed to various other similar offering viewed on the same day.

i.e. Mini, Yaris, Fabia (with the same engine) small Suziki, Volvo etc

The Audi was last viewed and said son was well bored with car viewing, so i was interested in what he saw in this particular vehicle.

He could not articulate anything specific except it "felt good" and there was enough room for his 18 stone bulk.

He was not particularly interested in what it looked like, though I am sure though if he was driving one he would soon twig the blind spot /visibility problems.

Cheers

m

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - jamie745

The term 'ugly' is banded about too easily now. The Chrysler PT Cruiser is ugly, so is the Fiat Multipla, original Kia Rio and Ssangyong Rexton.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Roly93

if overpriced as are most VW/Audi badged offerings, but it takes ugly to a whole new level.

People always say this about VW/Audi but we have a newish Ford and a newish Audi and you can definately see where the extra money went on the Audi. If you justy dont care at all about creaks and rattles then dont wast your money on a VW or Audi but they are dearer for a reason. After all that is why we dont all buy all of our furniture from Ikea or MFI when it was going !

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Avant

Absolutely, Roly, and cars that hold their value like an A1 don't seem so overpriced when it comes to trading them in. SWMBO is on her fourth Mini, and the first three have all been worth 80 % of original cost after two years as a PX against a new one..

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Buster Cambelt

I've had a few of these A1s as hire cars and I really rate them, especially the petrols, I find the diesel is pretty noisy and rough and the petrol cars are always very economical.

The 1.4 is great but don't discount the 1.2 as it is not at all what you'd expect.

It may seem expensive but I think this is a really class act.

But I've boycotted VAG so I should probably be saying how rubbish and over-rated their products are!

Edited by Buster Cambelt on 14/02/2012 at 20:24

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - concrete

Buster, pray tell! why have you boycotted VAG products? Concrete

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Sulphur Man

Perhaps the answer lies in his username. As Audi are still fitting VAG belt-cam 4 pot diesels to their parts bin....sorry, I mean "prestige" cars....

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Avant

Buster C had an unhappy experience with a Skoda. He was unlucky as satisfaction rates are very high for Skodas. But quite understandably he doesn't want to risk another VAG car, at least for now.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Buster Cambelt

Buster C had an unhappy experience with a Skoda. He was unlucky as satisfaction rates are very high for Skodas. But quite understandably he doesn't want to risk another VAG car, at least for now.

Well that's one way of putting it, take one excerable, badly built and unreliable Skoda. Add a handful of incompetent dealers, a pathological liar of a service manager and a wholly complacent manufacturer and you'll start to get close. Cost my business thousands, not just through poor reliability but continued inability to get first time fixes.

Over on the fan boy site this seems to be regarded as perfectly acceptable, in fact I should be grateful that I got to see my lovely Skoda dealer so often. Satisfaction rates are high on these heaps because expectation is so low, all JD Power and Co really measure is how you feel against how you expected to feel. I don't expect perfection, though I always strive for it, but I do expect top service all of the time. Skoda missed by a light year.

Not only did I bin the Skoda after 10 months I banned all VAG products from my company (and we BUY our cars LOCALLY).

End of rant.

The name is just, well, a daft name. The only car I've ever been in where the cambelt failed was a virtually new Toyota and I already had the monicker then.

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Roly93

Perhaps the answer lies in his username. As Audi are still fitting VAG belt-cam 4 pot diesels to their parts bin....sorry, I mean "prestige" cars....

I know some VaG diesels had problems with cambelt tensioner failure and subsequent cambelt failure which isn't good. However I had 2 VaG diesel engined cars with this potential problem and neither ever had a problem.

On my latest 4 pot VaG diesel i noticed that the cambelt change interval was something like at least 100K miles. I had a look at the cam belt under the covers and it does seem that they have berserkly over-engineered the whole setup, so I would not doubt the high mileage change now, ie lessons learnt...

Audi A1 Owners Views Wanted - Roly93

Absolutely, Roly, and cars that hold their value like an A1 don't seem so overpriced when it comes to trading them in. SWMBO is on her fourth Mini, and the first three have all been worth 80 % of original cost after two years as a PX against a new one..

To underpin this, my last A4 was 4 1/2 years old with nearly 60K, and I still sold it privately for 46% of its cost new. Most decent cars struggle to do this over 3 years and Ford/Vauxhall/Renault etc wouldnt have a snowballs chance.