Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?.

Honest John Back Room » Motoring discussion
View Threaded
Mon 30 Jan 2012 20:54
Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?. - Bigdaveg

I've had a fusion 1.4 tdci for 2 years and have a desire to replace it with something a little bigger (5 large'ish adults plus lugage), better, more reliable and without costing a fortune (tax, insurance etc), budget £5k.

I am not a big fan of Fords (I consider them unreliable, solely because everyone I've had has cost me a lot of money, in comparison to any other make) and having owned several Japanese cars (no problems and more reliable than my best Ford), I have shortlisted the following; Mazda 3 1.6ts diesel, Honda Civic 1.6 petrol & 1.7 cdti (which wife has), Honda Jazz, and the Citroen Xsara Picasso 2.0 hdi exclusive, strangely the Citroen and in pariticular the 2.0 hdi has some excellent user reviews, I did like the look of the cmax (pity Honda don't do something similar), but it's a ford & the write up on this web site ain't great. I absolutely love the C3 Picasso but it's way over budget.

Anybody have any thoughts, in particular which of the shortlisted cars would be my best bet ?.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 30 Jan 2012 21:06
Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?. - Avant

With 5 largeish adults I'd say it's between the Civic and the Picasso - old-shape Civic that is, which has as you know (asssuming that's what your wife has) lots of room in the back. You'd need a roof-box or rack for 5 people's luggage, which might fit in the Picasso. Maybe add the Toyota Verso to the shortlist. The Jazz is a good car but surely it hasn't any more room than a Fusion?

If you do fewer than 15,000 miles a year you probably don't need a diesel.

.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 30 Jan 2012 21:10
Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?. - gordonbennet

Kia Carens, proper automatic Diesel version too if required.

Agree with Verso, and the rare Avensis Verso is a superb car.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 30 Jan 2012 23:56
Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?. - Auristocrat
From the HJ reviews: Jazz boot space (rear seat upright) 353 litres, seats folded 1323; Fusion (rear seat upright) 318/337 litres, seats folded 1109 litres,
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Tue 31 Jan 2012 12:34
Replacing a Ford fusion 1.4 tdci, but what with ?. - Bigdaveg

Of the cars I have mentioned the Picasso has by far the biggest boot, the Boxy civic (the best one IMHO), is on a par with the Jazz, the Mazda 3 has the smallest boot.

That said literage is one thing but actual use-ability is another, the Civic's boot is bigger than my fusion, but the wheel wells hamper loading, a fusion does'nt have a boot lip or said wheel wells, so load wise it ain't as clear cut as people might think.

Rear leg & shoulder room are very important, 3 adults in the back of the fusion is do-able but not recommended, the springs are also naff, imho, the civic is a little better and having owned a Mazda 323 (a really nice "drivers" car), I would imagine the 3's not much better in the width department.

All this points to the Picasso, biggest boot, 3 individual removeable seats etc. Anything out there that's as reliable (in 2.0 hdi guise) ?. Ref the Verso, yep a really nice car "but" how big's the boot and could you squeeze some biggies in the back doors ?.. The Cmax & Citroen c3 picasso are about the size I'm after, sadly one's a ford and the other's way too pricey ;-(

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Cold-snap snow-how: Advice on coping with the freezing weather, including videos, facts and winter driving advice.

Honest John's Guide To Winter Tyres

If you cover no more than 100 miles per day and have easy access to a charging point at home or work, then an EV is ideal for you.

Is an electric car right for me?