Jeremy Clarkson............... - Trilogy

has done it again. Will the BEEB sack him. I expect next time he needs to use someone from the public sector he'll have a hard time.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Avant

More probably there will be a lot of outrage and it'll blow over. He clearly didn't mean it to be taken literally, but he tends to shoot from the hip and get his mouth in gear before his brain. The BBC would be silly to sack him as people want to watch him and ITV would snap him up.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - jamie745

Oh what a massive fuss over nothing. It was obvious at the time it was exaggerated for comic effect, only an idiot would take it seriously.......Ed Miliband took it seriously. People in this country need to lighten up and discover the location of the 'off' button on their TV remote. You book Jezza as a guest and thats what you're going to get, you watch Jezza on TV and thats what you expect to hear.

This countries getting worse. I couldnt believe the One Show felt the need to issue an apology when its so obvious it wasnt meant seriously, people just love feeling offended in this country for some reason its getting on my nerves. Thankfully the BBC arent stupid, Top Gear is worth too much to the BBC to axe Jezza as its their biggest export.

You say he's 'done it again' but thats only because the rest of the media has told everybody to be offended. I want to know how many of the 5000 who complained actually watched the show live. Because its Clarkson, people will complain, they always do. Because of these people, Clarkson keeps doing it.

God i need to get on a plane and go somewhere else. Really am sick of this place.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Bobbin Threadbare

He's done it before; he'll do it again. He gets some ridiculous amount for each Top Gear episode as well.

He ought to have considered that the BBC is, in effect, a public sector body though........

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Trilogy

I don't think he was being totally serious, but I do think he meant it.

Edited by Trilogy on 03/12/2011 at 20:34

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Trilogy

Following on, as its JC again, I can see where he's coming from...........uk.news.yahoo.com/clarkson-hits-rail-suicides-0203...l

Jeremy Clarkson............... - jamie745

I saw this earlier and to be honest i think he has a point. Ive always felt if someone wants to kill themselves then fine, get on with it. But dont jump in front of trains or lorries or do it in a way which involves other innocent people having to live with the images of it. Throw yourself off a bridge or take a load of pills if you want to die.

They may be put out of their misery but the Train Driver doesnt get such a luxury. I know somebody who used to be a Lorry driver until the day someone stood at the side of an NSL road he was on and leapt in front of his Lorry at the last minute on purpose, he hasnt been able to get behind the wheel of a car since - let alone a lorry - and he had to give up his job because of the experience.

I dont think Clarkson really wants public sector workers shot in a serious sense - you'd have to be an idiot to take that comment seriously - but he probably doesnt agree with the strikes. But Clarkson does what he does, people love being offended by him so he keeps himself in the news - call my cynical but its odd a Clarkson-Controversy crops up just as his new book and DVD comes out a few weeks before Top Gear's return.

He's put a serious point over in his column today but has done his usual of saying it in a silly way so as people dont - or shouldnt - take it seriously. If he took himself seriously and expected others to do so then he'd give himself responsibility, he doesnt want that.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Trilogy

Jamie, I agree with everything you've said. That's not always the case, but it is this time.

I have a friend who lost her daughter through suicide. She jumped from a bridge. No vehicle or train was involved. Fortunately I've never contemplated taking my own life but would like to think I wouldn't do it so it traumatises someone because I've stood in front of a train/vehicle.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Carole4X4
I recall a BTP officer saying exactly the same thing in a programme called Rail Cops a few years ago, she described people who commit suicide as selfish because the train driver can't do anything except brake whereas a car driver etc may be able to steer and not cause as serious or fatal injury.
No controversy then if I recall correctly but then the BTP officer wasn't as high profile as JC.

I am not a Clarkson fan and personally think he is a complete and utter idiot, I've never watched Top Gear since he became the main presenter, and couldn't really care less at what he says but this time I think the uproar is because of who said it and not what was said. As for his comments on the striking public sector workers then that was tasteless, disrespectful and downright patronising, he doesn't work as hard as public sector workers such as refuse collectors, nurses, teachers, dinner ladies etc and he won't need to worry about a pension if he looks after his BBC ( licence payers ) salary effectively.

Just my tuppence worth.
Jeremy Clarkson............... - jamie745

No controversy then if I recall correctly but then the BTP officer wasn't as high profile as JC.

Left-wing media nutcases arent oddly terrified that 100% of the British public is a disciple of a BTP officer. For some reason the hysterical left seems to think if they dont all condemn Clarkson then everybody will do as he says. Why are they so afraid of him?

As for his comments on the striking public sector workers then that was tasteless, disrespectful and downright patronising, he doesn't work as hard as public sector workers such as refuse collectors, nurses, teachers, dinner ladies etc

Practically every comedian or satirist has an easier life than someone who goes to work and does a proper job and the vast majority of comedy is jokes made at someone elses expense. If we decided you couldnt make a joke about someone who works harder than you then this would be a very strange place to live.

On the subject of the strikes themselves all i'll say is im getting extremely bored of people moaning about pensions. I cannot support the disruption that these strikes bring to honest, ordinary working people. Theres people i work with who are paid less than a teacher and have no pension lined up at all who had to take the day off work to look after children as a result of these strikes. Thats not right.

You say 'he doesnt work has hard as public sector workers' as though public sector workers are the only people who work hard. Theres millions in the private sector who work hard, probably even harder but they dont have anybody to strike against either. They just get on with it, they dont sit outside holding signs and crying on BBC Lunchtime news.

For me the best bit of The One Show was Alex Jones' face when Clarkson came out with that comment. You could almost hear the Producer having a heart attack in her ear.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Leif

I find it depressing that so many people are up in arms when Clarkson was so obviously using hyperbole for comedic effect. When we can no longer have black humour, hyperbole and absurdity, then we are truly doomed.

Anyway, I think the anger is politically motivated, as a reaction to a perceived criticism of the strikers. It seems to me, that the criticism is largely from the left, which has always struck me as being rather po faced and sanctimonious.

Jeremy Clarkson............... - jamie745

Of course its politically motivated, its worth mentioning the on-air apology from the One Show was actually in response to Clarkson's comments about people jumping in front of trains. The BBC did not apologise for his comments about the strikers yet the Unions portray it as 'Clarkson was forced to apologise for criticising us!' as so many of the Unions and public sector strikers - at least the ones on the news - seem convinced the entire planet revolves around them.

The Unions see the BBC as their channel so in the interests of balance they were supposed to put a Labour peer on the One Show to back up the poor strikers instead. To be honest the joke was more about the BBC's insane need for 'balance' which is often hilarious. Its being used a political weapon because Jezza was Cameron's next door neighbour so Clarkson's comments are portrayed as carrying extra weight because of this. The key point is that these strikes dont have the universal public support the strikers think they do, a poll on the Telegraph showed the majority of the public back the Government on this and any tiny piece of criticism - hyperbolic, joking or otherwise - in their view must be stamped out.

If anybody had any class then the only thing we shouldve been discussing from Clarkson's interview was the section about Help for Heroes and his journies meeting soldiers and discussions about the conditions they were in before the charity formed but thanks to Unions making a fuss over nothing that part of the interview has been forgotten. Some of these gormless stone faced Union leaders - some of whom earn 150k in a year yet claim to stick up for the little person - remind me of those people who take everything as a personal insult. The sort of person who goes 'why is that traffic light red, it must be done just to annoy me.'

Jeremy Clarkson............... - madf

When Public Service workers take as few sick days as private sector workers, I will belive they works as hard.

Until then, the figures say they don't.

(Some of the problem is undoubtedly p poor management)

Jeremy Clarkson............... - nollienolan

YAWN!!!!Boring!

Jeremy Clarkson............... - Avant

Your first post on the forum: welcome, but may we look forward to a more substantial contribution from you in days to come?

Jeremy Clarkson............... - 475TBJ

Good job I don't get sick too often. Nobody pays me if I have a day off.