Sat nav days numbered? - barney100

By this I mean the tom tom Garmi types. the new android mobile 'phones have google sat nav on them and I have to say they are really a match or better than the traditonal ones. The screens aren't as large but I prefer the phone system.

Sat nav days numbered? - jamie745

If its on a phone are you allowed to use it while driving? :P

Sat nav days numbered? - colinh

Given they currently rely on receiving a signal whilst on the move,don't rely on one in the more out-of-way places,like my local mountainous national park area

Sat nav days numbered? - TeeCee

Google maps is to sat nav what Ssangyong is to cars.

Very cheap and sort of works, but it's a bit ugly and you wouldn't want to use it for any length of time.

Screen size, perspective view, junction layout, lane designation, maps on device so it works when disconnected from the world (etc. ad infinitum).

As with most things, you get what you paid for.

Sat nav days numbered? - Ethan Edwards

I disagree. As a stand alone device I'd say it's days are definitely numbered. Convergence my man!

There will always be a small niche for built in systems but I'd lay good money that the iphone/Android etc integration into car hifi's will continue much further and at increasing speed.

Already mainstream cars can use the personal mobile device -pmd to store/play music etc. And to provide telephony. Both mine do.

I predict Google search will be popular (already a feature on a few new Renaults) and many more features will be fully integrated into the phone/ incar tech dock.

Just speculating but how about.....

Rear camera's? Video recording of journeys (great for insurance claims), Remote start? Radio, EX parrallel parking, black box recording etc. Maybe you'll use your phone to voice change in car stuff, lights, heater etc.

Exciting times.

Sat nav days numbered? - TeeCee

All well and good, but when you buy that second hand Ford Fircone and find that it's not compatible with the current iPhad 8, you're a bit stuffed?

There's "must do 'cos it's trendy" and there's automotive design. One thinks of obsolescence in months, the other in decades.

Now, if we had a standard, fully-featured interface[1] and set of APIs across all phones, we might be going somewhere here. However, as differentiation and lock-in is the lifeblood of the phone industry (and the only thing that keeps Apple in business at all), you will grow old and die waiting for that to happen.

Personally I happen to like the integrated approac. Not being dependant on having ${device} on me and having to festoon the inside of the car with cables, suckers and holders is a major plus in my book.

[1] We were sooo nearly there with USB, then Apple came up with their proprietary "dock" connector and scuppered us.

Sat nav days numbered? - Bobbin Threadbare

I have a Samsung Galaxy phone with an Android-based system. Google maps serves me very well; my phone screen is large and it's a nice shiny AMOLED one anyway. You can put traffic layers on the maps to see where to avoid as well. It's quick and it does speak to you like a satnav. Personally I turn that off and glance at it now and then, using the road signs as well (which I have noticed a lot of satnav users don't bother with...!)

Sat nav days numbered? - Ethan Edwards

SGS2? I have the Galaxy S bought it just before the SGS2 was launched. I love it!!

Edited by Ethan Edwards on 26/09/2011 at 23:00

Sat nav days numbered? - davecooper

"There will always be a small niche for built in systems but I'd lay good money that the iphone/Android etc integration into car hifi's will continue much further and at increasing speed."

Why would I prefer the relatively piddly screen size of smart phone to the large integrated display fitted to my car? This is perfectly placed, free from glare and displays a host of other car info as well and is operated from the steering wheel controls. Also, announcements from the integrated system mute the car entertainment system. I also have a usb storage device, containing my whole music library, in the car which is integrated into the car system.

I cannot see why I would ever want to use my phone to replace all of this.

Sat nav days numbered? - Ethan Edwards

The latest Samsung smartphone has a 4.65 inch screen. It's likely that screen sizes will increase over time.

If the dock was centrally placed and high enough thats already large enough to use in say a small city car. The quality of the Samsung screen is far superior to any and I mean ANY oem one fitted to any present car.

In fact in your post you've made some of my case for me quoting the extensive integration that you already enjoy.

Edited by Ethan Edwards on 27/09/2011 at 17:13

Sat nav days numbered? - Wicker

Yep, on a recent trip to Spain didn't even bother to take the TomTom, as I have installed an application called "N Drive" on my very cheap unlocked San Francisco Android phone. N Drive has local stored maps unlike Google maps and so does not need a data connection.

IMHO as soon as someone "ports" the Tom Tom System to Android that's it for stand alone sat nav units.

Sat nav days numbered? - xtrailman

I bought a nokia smart phone last year, primarily for use as a walking satnav, just so i could find my way back to the parked car, and with a better quality camera for if i have a car accident.

I found the nokia quite useless unless you logged on, the satellite location is pathetic, and the screen virtually unreadable in bright sunshine.

Admittedly it didn't cost the same as a I phone, less than £100 in fact.

Anyway after a year I've bought a cheap Garmin, in contrast the Garmin is brilliant, and does exactly what i want, i for one have no interest in another smart phone, my next purchase will be bought for texts, calls, and again with a decent camera. I prefer my laptop with a large screen for the internet.

Will it make a standard fit car satnav redundant?, not a chance i will always buy a car with fitted satnav, again a big screen, conveniently fitted with blue tooth and voice commands.

Sat nav days numbered? - Death51
I agree standalone satnav units will die but not inbuilt car satnav. You see cars are all coming now with infotainment systems with large screens as standard. The next step logically will be Internet access for on the move with live traffic updates etc. Basically the car makers will port a version of google satnav into their infotainment systems.

This will have the added bonus that carmakers will no longer be able to charge the ridiculous prices for the current systems.
Sat nav days numbered? - davecooper

The glare on the screen is an important issue. On a bright day, the glare on my phone screen makes it impossible to see wherever it is placed. The integrated system tucks the screen deep enough into the dash to prevent any glare.

Increasing the size of smartphone screens is pointless in my opinion as you then start moving toward tablet size. I don't want something the size of a paperback in my pocket.

I can understand that some people are keen to have everything, and do everything on one device and I have no problem with that. However, for me, it's horses for courses. I manage a couple of web sites and I certainly wouldn't work on these sites via Smartphone.

Sat nav days numbered? - dacouch

My friend works in high end electronics and told me a couple of years that he had seen a demonstration of 3D Sat nav. It worked on the same principle of a head up display but instead of the image you have on a normal sat nav you had a large arrow which appeared near the front of your bonnet showing you which way to go.

He said it was much easier to use than a normal sat nav

Apparantly they had nearly perfected the technology but need to clear the legalities of it.

Sat nav days numbered? - oldroverboy

I have tried various satnavs from when they got below £200 and have preferred the navman series. I have also had ovi maps on my last 3 nokia phones, which do not require a data connection as google maps does, think of those data charges! the latest N8 gives me maps for the middle east for when I am there too, and will also be good for canada next year, screen size is good and this phone has a mount that is below dashboard level, I have also been able to download the nokia "safety camera app, and with a bit of luck can get the same for europe. One of the good things with the nokia is that I can set the overspeed warning differently for limits below and above 50 mph and 70mph (zero tolerance below 50 and 5 mph above 70 ) and also as with others has several thousand music tracks, generally on random play, so does all I want. Went with a friend to europe and his tom-tom ixl was useless.

Sat nav days numbered? - carl_a

Google satnav is good but having to connect to the Internet is a pain in some locations. CoPilot works rather well for around £20 from Android market and doesn't need live Internet.

One of the car manufactures will break ranks at some point and offer inbuilt sat-nav as a reasonable price or pretty much standard fit. Toyota tried it a while back on the Avensis but that just pointed with arrows on a B&W screen. Mitsubishi did a talking system when they launched the Colt but they took that out rather quickly.

Sat nav days numbered? - Death51
Google satnav uses very little data, so the charges are minimal. In fact I used mine in Sicily and Italy recently and it never went near my included data allowance of 25mb a day (vodafone data traveller), think the most it used was 2.6mb. I also have Co-pilot on my phone but rarely use it.

You can also use wifi for the initial map/route and a lot of the map is cached to the phone so any re-routes etc do not have to use data. Google satnav and expensive data charges is a myth tbh.

Don't forget the maps are constantly updated for free, include traffic data, and interact with google itself. So you can search for anything in the search window and if it has a location etc it will show you/phone no/street view picture/reviews. As an example I was going to a wedding last week searched 'kilt hire' in google maps showed me all in vicinity, directions, links to website etc. For free it puts standalone satnavs to shame at the prices they charge especially for the 'extras' that the higher ones supposedly offer with subscription lol.
Sat nav days numbered? - rpmmatt

Look out for some sat nav software called Sygic. It works for multiple OS's and most smart phones. It's not to pricey and all the maps are stored locally on the phone, so no data charges and no loss of maps due to poor reception.

Its also very easy to use, and very well intergrated with the phones contact/address book.