Rent a car or take my own ? - kentdave1973
Given the choice between taking my own 2004 2 litre petrol Mondeo on holiday or renting an underpowered but new 1.8 Insignia petrol, what should I do ?
Rent a car or take my own ? - Death51
Well I wouldn't say your mondeo is a powerhouse compared to the insignia, there is only 5 bhp difference ! As for your question it depends how far your travelling and how long for?
Rent a car or take my own ? - Collos25

And what country,a new Insignia is a little hard to compare with a 7 year old Ford it will be better in every way possible.

Edited by Collos25 on 03/09/2011 at 22:31

Rent a car or take my own ? - kentdave1973
Kent to Cornwall and hills. I think my decision is made then, only I've read that the 1.8 petrol struggles with the weight of the car. Rented a 1.9 diesel 104 bhp Passat once and wasn't impressed to be honest.
Rent a car or take my own ? - mlj

Sorry, but when I read the OP I assumed some daunting European jaunt was at hand. Kent to Cornwall? Some hills? Unless the Mondeo is currently unreliable why would anyone incur extra expense?

Or is it me?

Rent a car or take my own ? - pd

Well, you could always ask the hire company nicely for a 2.0 CDTi version! (They don't have many petrols usually anyway).

If there is more than one of you going and/or you have found the world's cheapest train ticket it has to be cheaper to take your own car.

Rent a car or take my own ? - gordonbennet

Already own a perfectly capable car, considering hiring a similarly sized one.

For what purpose, unless you fancy trying an Insignia out for a few days with a view to buying, which does make sense.

As for power, i imagine the Insignia is perfectly capable of reaching speeds that will result in an automatic driving ban.

Rent a car or take my own ? - kentdave1973
Thanks for the replies - sarcastic and otherwise. Yes it's with a view to buying. I obviously shouldn't have asked the question in this forum.
Rent a car or take my own ? - colinh

Assumed it was Kent, Ohio

Rent a car or take my own ? - unthrottled

I'm popping down to the shops for some bread and milk. I am unsure whether to walk, cycle or take the car. Could the forum advise?

Rent a car or take my own ? - mlj

Sliced or unsliced? White or wholemeal?

Skimmed, semi-skimmed or whole milk?

Quantity and volume?

Hard to say when asked such a vague question............

Rent a car or take my own ? - gordonbennet

I'm popping down to the shops for some bread and milk. I am unsure whether to walk, cycle or take the car. Could the forum advise?

Well now, after careful consideration for all of 14 seconds....

Walk....hmm it's raining here, so that will mean the umbrella will have to come out, no point in going without taking the dog for a walk, so you have two problems now, once loaded with bread and milk you will have either no hand for the brolly or no hand for the dog's lead, that means either you should have sported a wide brimmed titfer and forgon the brolly, or you should have schooled your dog to walk at heel perfectly. Factor in some busybody will disapprove of you tying the dog up outside whilst you shop, then you'll be delayed fending off some bod from the RSPCA ...so, walkings out.

Cycle...again the rain, you'll need to waterproof yourself, which is a pita, means digging out the sou'wester and bright yellow cape, fixing the statutory flat tyre before departure which means removing and redonning the aforesaid waterproofs, then you've got to find the padlock you thought was attached to the bike, but the kids borrowed it 12 months ago, which is incidentally the last time you rode, so you'll wobble and end up under the wheels of a bus..so, cyclings out.

Take the car...not really the sort of thing that's good for the environment is it, couldn't you wait for the bus that's probably due monday at 0915, but will be cancelled. Assuming you're the archtypical antisocial car owner that still expects to use the car he paid for, hmmfph, you start the car and get going towards the shop. It's probaly one mile away, but in the interests of the environment the anti car council has rearranged the one way system so you have to drive round terraced streets past two hospitals and four childrens play areas, a total of 6 miles to get back to the shop, when you get there a jobsworth with a sense of humour bypass will charge you £1.40 for the privelidge of parking. You have to wait 20 minutes till the the first person returns thereby vacating a space, they can't drive and they've driven into the space, which means they'll take 16 shunts to back out, just as you go to drive in the space you run out of fuel, you go and get some fuel and finally park. You get your shopping, and return to find you've overtstayed your time slot and jobsworth is trying not to show his evil axe murderer smirk as he's put a £60 ticket on your car for overstay, this doesn't bother you too much though as the family from hell with 6 kids have parked beside you and the neanderthals have opended both doors onto your car and put dents in it, and you've got a flat tyre because the winos and drug addicts use the car park at night and you've driven onto broken glass...so drivings out.

Oh and if you're still reading this you're a daft as i am, Go online and get it delivered.

Rent a car or take my own ? - bathtub tom

And I thought I had a reputation for stirring?

Boring, wet, Sunday afternoon eh gb? Try watching the BTCC from Knockhill.

Rent a car or take my own ? - gordonbennet

And I thought I had a reputation for stirring?

It's fair cop guv you got me bang to rights..

Having a peruse for a while before i'm off to work, but don't you go worrying about me alone keeping the country fed, i'll just tilt me halo to a jaunty angle and carry on regardless.

:--))

Rent a car or take my own ? - unthrottled

Stll reading?

...Go on-best laugh I've had in ages!

Rent a car or take my own ? - jamie745

Just a shame his post was disgracefully too long. Avant will not like that.

Rent a car or take my own ? - Bobbin Threadbare

But it's a beautiful day - sunny, warm and not even breezy. I say get a Segway. This will save any future hassle when unthrottled is Minister for Transport and he opens up the journey possibilities for the UK.

Rent a car or take my own ? - jamie745

I'll take Minister for Transport, Unthrottled can be home secretary. Avant will be ideal in the role of Prime Minister, a good presenter who can say alot of words in a very reasonable way.

Rent a car or take my own ? - Bobbin Threadbare

So it's up to the women to do the real work then...!

Rent a car or take my own ? - jamie745

You can be my bit on the side, customary for all high ranking politicians.

Rent a car or take my own ? - unthrottled

Jamie, you're on form tonight!

Rent a car or take my own ? - Bobbin Threadbare

<cracks knuckles>

Who's up for the first a***-kicking....?!

Rent a car or take my own ? - Avant

Are you seeing me in the role of kicker, Bobbin? - I hope not!

Kentdave - some of us on here have a quirky sense of humour, but don't be offended. If you'd said tnat the hire was to try out a possible successor to your Mondeo, you'd probably have got some more informative comments. Personally I'd suggest that you take your own car and use the (considerable) amount saved in having nicer holiday accommodation or a few good meals out.

GB - brilliant! Nothing wrong with length when it's funny.

Rent a car or take my own ? - kentdave1973

Are you seeing me in the role of kicker, Bobbin? - I hope not!

Kentdave - some of us on here have a quirky sense of humour, but don't be offended. If you'd said tnat the hire was to try out a possible successor to your Mondeo, you'd probably have got some more informative comments. Personally I'd suggest that you take your own car and use the (considerable) amount saved in having nicer holiday accommodation or a few good meals out.

GB - brilliant! Nothing wrong with length when it's funny.

Thanks for your reply. I didn't think of it as a successor until I looked more closely at how cheap one can be had - and I've recently had a payrise :). Problem being is that the furthest my car usually goes is 2 miles to the station and 2 miles back. In case anyone is interested - I was given a 1.8 petrol. With 3 other adults and a bootful of luggage, it really struggles especially on the A39 around Porlock Hill/Lynmouth where 1st gear was needed. Fuel consumption was shown as 31 mpg over 300 miles but this was doing 80 on mways. I wish I had taken my own car to be honest. Similar mpg but more performance.

Edited by kentdave1973 on 06/09/2011 at 11:35

Rent a car or take my own ? - concrete

You can be my bit on the side, customary for all high ranking politicians.

As was said when John 2 Jags Prescott was caught with the proverbials down, it was the power. It is supposed to be an aphrodisiac. But as SWMBO said looking at Prescotts photo

'No one is THAT powerful'

Cheers Concrete

Rent a car or take my own ? - unthrottled

Prescott was an oaf. Thank God we don't have to suffer him any more. Apart from when Newsnight inexplicably feel compelled to wheel him out to comment on a story.

Rent a car or take my own ? - jamie745

Prescott's a laugh. His time as Transport Minister was pretty painful for Britains motorists but Prescott is a good laugh. I mean when was the last time you saw a member of a recently elected Government punch a member of the public in the face? I cant see Theresa May doing that, or William Hague.

Rent a car or take my own ? - ForumNeedsModerating

Prescott, god bless 'im, reminds me when he speaks of Eric Morecambe's piano playing technique, as described by Eric as '..I can play all the right notes, but not necessarily in the right order..'