Age & Mileage - mike1976

Assuming 2 cars were the same price - is it more sensable to go with something newer, but with more miles - or one that is older but with less miles?

eg: Late 2007 & 60,000 miles - or Early 2006 & 40,000 miles

Age & Mileage - davmal
If it's a german car, it doesn't matter. They are incapable of ever going wrong or showing their age.
Age & Mileage - Collos25

Thats a sweeping statement I live in Germany and see plenty of garages all doing good business repairing cars.

Age & Mileage - mrnikko

Oh so german cars never go wrong try telling that to our service manager who has a Passat less than four years old now having a £4500 new gerbox fitted not a happy bunny I can tell you especially as V W don't want to know. Funny just had all VAG group cars taken off our company car lists as well.

Age & Mileage - ddr

With that small amount of difference, both those factors are irrelevant. Go by condition and service history.

Age & Mileage - unthrottled

Quite. However in answer to OP, in general it is better to have a newer car with a high annual mileage than an older one with a low annual mileage.

Age & Mileage - Bobbin Threadbare

There's almost nothing in those!!

It depends what the car is - think about the type of parts it might need too; an old or unusual vehicle or a high spec one will need pricey parts for repair. A newer vehicle might have a lower tax band as the car companies are sorting out the emissions.

My other half drives a 75k miles 2003 car, but it's a damn sight better than my mum's 2006 20k miles car.

You've got to balance the whole package.

Age & Mileage - bbc123

My preference would be for a younger, higher-mileage car than an older, lower-mileage car. Full service history a must as well; minimise the risks where possible.

Age & Mileage - Lord Laughton

Newer high mileage car imo. Usually motorway miles and ex company car/lease car which will have been serviced regularly and no expense spared in doing so. Often much higher spec than you would otherwise be able to afford. Motorway miles = constant speed, not stop/start ,much less wear and tear on gear box and steady revs, not boy racer driving!

Age & Mileage - madf

"Usually motorway miles and ex company car/lease car which will have been serviced regularly and no expense spared in doing so"

Hmmm..

Not in any company I worked in. Ever. Cheapest job possible. Never serviced before being sold. Tyres not changed if being sold. We never spent money needlessly on cars...

Age & Mileage - Lord Laughton

Quite. Buyer beware and do your research. I can but go off my own experience. I scoured the trader and did my research on this site and others. In the end I went an ex company car via a dealer. I hpi checked it via the txt message check, rang up the previous company who owned it - many miles away from dealer so I doubt they knew each other and contacted the BMW garage where all the very expensive on time services had been carried out. They again verified the legitimacy of the milage and vehicle Looking at the service manual, I was able speak with the mechanic who worked on the vehicle and he gave me a run down of the work done at each service. If you do your homework and follow the advice of many on this site, a high milage company car should pose no issues and you will pick up a bargain if you haggle!!! Incidently in the line of work I am in it is a discplinary offence to even drive a vehicle over it's service schedule!!!!

Age & Mileage - WellKnownSid

Hmm indeed!

Once picked up an 18 month old Nissan Primera "pool car" with so many faults that I refused to drive it. After much arguing I eventually got given a hire car.

To prove a point one of the managers then took said Nissan out, only to be stopped by the Police about 10 miles up the road. The metal-on-metal noise from the remains of the front disks was enough to break glass apparently!

Age & Mileage - Lord Laughton

Do your homework, appears to be the moto. I have had a good experience with my 320d (so far) as have friends of mine - usually with German cars. But as theses chaps have stated there are some dogs out there. I did incidentaly learn the hard way. I once bought an older saab 93 the, 150 tid engine with very low miles 35000 and it was awful from day1! Inlet manifold, ECU and ignition system, ERG valve, front suspension - 2 batteries, repeat turbo problems and the icing on the cake was the front saab badge coming off. That was in the space of about 6 months and I'd only covered approx 8000 miles when I got rid.

Age & Mileage - veryoldbear

Ignition system on a TID?

Age & Mileage - Lord Laughton

Sorry wrong wording. To clarify - the bit where you insert the silly pear shaped saab key to start the thing. On the saab it's down near the handbrake. Well it refused to accept the key and the car wouln't start. That was approx a month after buying it, close to Christmas and cost a fortune to replace. Saab 93 tid Vector Sport worst car I ever owned.